29 ms·
Someone recently pointed out to me the parallels between prostitution and labor. And I kind of can't shake it out of my head now, since I feel you can draw pret
by Workaccount2 5y ago
Someone recently pointed out to me the parallels between prostitution and labor. And I kind of can't shake it out of my head now, since I feel you can draw pretty straight lines from one to the other.
Both are selling your body for (relatively) high pay. Both have you burn out usually by your mid-late 40's. Both are dangerous work. Both have high degree's of human trafficking*. Both subsist mostly on young naïve workers. Both have no education requirements. Both have success predicated greatly on genetics (strength vs. looks). Both are the oldest professions in the world.
Really the most substantial difference I can see is in how society values men vs. women, dispensable vs. protected. Which is of course the same way humans valued men and women for pretty much all of history.
*Trafficking is tricky because in the US it's basically if you do (illegal) sex work and have a boss you are being trafficked. Basically everyone in construction would be "trafficked" then, so instead I go with a high degree of desperate illegal immigrants who will do really any work (ripe for exploitation).
Edit: I should note that my take is that prostitution should be legalized, regulated, unionized, and not stigmatized. It should be on the same social rung as labor.
- seph-reed 5y agoI think the one big emotional difference which has put prostitution in a separate category is that it kind of overlaps with drugs and addiction. Sex releases happy chemicals, just like drugs. Nobody is getting hooked on paying people to pour concrete. There's the saying "if you look for yellow cars, you'll find them." I think your assumption that the difference was gender is just a product of the times: you were looking for that answer. Even though male prostitutes are illegal too. And there's clearly an emotional difference between having sex with someone, and having them mow your lawn.
- float4 5y ago> Nobody is getting hooked on paying people to pour concrete. So you think sex work is illegal / made very impractical in so many countries to protect the customers?
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoOnly one is a transmissible disease vector that presents a threat to all of society.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Y_Y 5y agoThese things aren't illegal soas to protect the unfortunates who would become addicted, so much as the society as a whole. So that (most) people don't just give up and smoke crack all day or become too immoral or whatever. In principle at least, every individual vice has it's own complicated story.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- u20210623 5y ago>There's the saying "if you look for yellow cars, you'll find them." I think your assumption that the difference was gender is just a product of the times: you were looking for that answer. Without passing an opinion on the subject, isn't that kind of a flaming laser sword? You could apply it to any parallel drawn between two things regardless of whether the comparison is valid or not. It doesn't seem like a useful tool to discriminate valid ideas from invalid ones.
- saithound 5y agoThis form of argument does not seem to apply to every parallel drawn between any two things. It seems to apply specifically to comparisons that are very close fits with dominant cultural trends. In 1800s Britain, it could be applied to reject claims such as "cholera is caused by the jews", but it could not be applied to claims such as "cholera is caused by contaminated water pumps". Similarly, the claim "prostitution was made illegal because the Plumbers and Deliverypeople Union wanted exclusive nibs on spontaneous sexual encounters" would be impervious to this 'sword', because blaming plumbers for the problems of society is not a current trope of our culture. Disregarding the merits of this particular instance, that seems like a reasonable general heuristic: after all, if some conclusion is socially desirable, then people may reach it even when it's not supported by the preponderance of evidence.
- u20210623 5y agoWhy couldn't it? The statement has nothing to do with current tropes, but rather is an implicit accusation of a confirmation bias on a single person. You can make a claim, and regardless of what it is I can reply with "well, you're saying that because you have an a priori belief and you were looking for any evidence to confirm it".
- saithound 5y agoThe statement has a lot to do with current tropes: that's exactly what "product of the times" means. Cf. a "sign of the times": something that shows the kinds of things that are happening, popular, important, etc., in a culture at a particular period in history.
- Workaccount2 5y ago~~If you watch any interviews with sex workers it's clear that they view it as a job, not as a pleasure act. Many porn stars for instance have boyfriends/husbands and note that sex with them is different then their day job sex.~~ Also I am talking more about hard labor, construction, dock work, mining, landscaping is is taxing but it doesn't pay the big sell-your-back-knees-and-possibly-a-limb bucks.
- frenchy 5y agoYou misunderstood. The people who presumably get 'hooked' aren't the workers, but the customers. People don't sell drugs as a pleasure act either.
- Workaccount2 5y agoAh, I see.
- 8note 5y agosuccess and completing things also release happy chemicals, but we you're allowed to build things or play sports for payment. Even with that emotional connection, both psychologists and masseuses exist just fine
- seph-reed 5y agoI've made a few friends in life who've done pretty much every drug under the sun. The only one that I've consistently heard described as "better than sex" is heroin. Please, reflect on that for a second. Imagine going through all the drugs you could, trying heroin, and being like: "woah, this one drug is actually better than sex." It says a lot.
- csomar 5y ago> Both are dangerous work Because the regulation is crappy. Current regulation and laws is what made them dangerous. > Both have high degree's of human trafficking Again. This is due to the current laws. If woman were able to travel to another country (say, USA) and do short-term entertainment work for a few months on her own terms, you will reduce human trafficking. The current laws benefit lots of people. For politicians, this problem doesn't exist since prostitution is illegal. For human traffickers and clubs, this brings them money because if woman were to operate legally on a freelance basis, they'll have no business mode. The customers don't really care.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> For human traffickers and clubs, this brings them money because if woman were to operate legally on a freelance basis, they'll have no business mode. Operating legally on a freelance basis is the norm for strippers right now. The club's business model is that they charge the stripper for use of the floor.
- xf1cf 5y ago> If woman were able to travel to another country (say, USA) and do short-term entertainment work for a few months on her own terms, you will reduce human trafficking. I don't think this would be the case. Organized crime isn't black/white. They'd simply create a system of room rentals in love hotels or something and take the vig while corrupting prostitute unions (thereby allowing trafficking) or something similar. The mafia is quite famous for the tactic and I wouldn't be surprised if other more modern organized crime families have an even more lucrative business.
- potatoman22 5y ago> If woman were able to travel to another country (say, USA) and do short-term entertainment work for a few months on her own terms, you will reduce human trafficking. I don't think regulation would fix this. Is the main impetus for human trafficking the inability for sex workers to independently travel? Doesn't fit my mental model of the issue.
- 5y ago
- rytor718 5y agoYou're missing one: those who literally actually have the power have somehow been subsumed by a system into becoming powerless. Ergo, if workers realized that their work was valuable and created a bloc, we can turn the tables (unions come to mind as well as brothels and other collectives which seek to harness their power). The trick is you have to know you're powerful. And I'm not suggesting that's enough to solve the entire problem, but its enough to enable negotiations to continue improving the situation.
- bryondowd 5y agoIf you create a bloc of people providing a service that is illegal, now you've formed a criminal organization, at least in the eyes of law enforcement, and you've painted a target on your back. Can't really unionize effectively unless you're on the right side of the law. Which is another argument for decriminalization.
- Karsteski 5y agoThis is how I feel about many things that are illegal as well. We can sell our physical and mental health to our employers till the day we die, yet there are people imprisoned because of sex/drug crimes? Absolute insanity if you step back and look at it. Even worse is that in a country like the US, they practically have their own version of slavery with how inmates are effectively forced into labour for insignificant wages, which then benefit private corporations. This is definitely an aspect of humanity that will be looked upon very poorly in the future.
- scottyah 5y agoMy apologies if you're mainly talking about relatively harmless drugs like weed/psychedelics, but the hard drugs like meth and heroin are absolutely devastating to humans and I don't see any benefit to legalizing their sale. I realize drug dealers aren't forcing anyone to take them, but seeing what meth can do to a community is horrifying to the point where I feel most would agree it shouldn't happen (which is what laws are for). Certainly the way our prison systems run needs a major overhaul, but imprisonment due to permanently destroying lives, their potential children's lives, and communities for personal monetary gain (drug trafficking) does not sound like absolute insanity.
- jessaustin 5y agoNo one would become a meth addict if better drugs were cheap and legal. Even meth addicts would probably prefer some nice cocaine. Eventually, the most effective treatments for addiction will include supervised doses of psilocybin. Research is difficult when the law interferes, however.
- Karsteski 5y agoI am extremely against criminalization for any drugs, regardless of their impact to the person. Yes, some drugs are horrible and people should not take them. That does not mean ruining their lives and imprisoning them is something to even consider. Especially given that their family's lives are impacted even more so from them being absent, and the worse yet the dark cloud that continues to follow them for the rest of their lives now that they have federal charges, which makes them discriminated against for employment and forces crime through desperation. Harmful drugs and drug addiction should be treated through education, healthcare and community involvement. It actually disgusts me at this point that people think drug criminalization is a good thing despite what prisons are in much of the world.
- nwatson 5y agoThe very unparallel difference between prostitution and labor though (pre-modern-technology) is that the former often left a permanent, enduring, and very personal reminder of the activity ... a child. That's the genesis of almost all differences in treatment of prostitution vs labor, the one almost all commentators here have not addressed. With the "Brave New World" upon us in increasing degrees, that may change. EDIT: Brave New World
- DoreenMichele 5y agoDisease control is possibly a more compelling argument. I've seen some articles that suggest some prostitutes primarily provide oral gratification which does not lead to pregnancy. Your argument also presumes that all sex work is heterosexual which is another problem with it. Human sexual morality is complex. Disease control and the consequence of pregnancy are large parts of the reason sex is such a loaded issue. This is a poor argument for suggesting people should not be allowed to provide sexual services for cash if they so choose.
- ranguna 5y ago100% agree. That might look like only one difference, but it makes all the difference here. Aside from that, you also have the personal aspect of the two. When you leave labor related work and go to your house, you don't generally do labor on your own or with other people you share an interest (or a deep emotion with) with, you might do it as an hobby, but that's pretty much it. Sex on the other hand, is different. You can still do it without any emotions attached, but you also do it when you are deeply involved with other people. It's one of the basic ways to share deep affection with other people, which can be hindered if you do it professionally. Of course this depends on the person, or more generally, the society. Maybe that's probably why prostitution is legal in some countries.