6 ms·
There has always been tension amongst women’s rights advocates regarding sex work. One faction held (paraphrasing) that sex work was liberating (economically),
by mc32 5y ago
There has always been tension amongst women’s rights advocates regarding sex work. One faction held (paraphrasing) that sex work was liberating (economically), the other that sex work was denigrating and exploitative (sex objects).
- jandrese 5y agoThis is such a well known phenomenon that there is a shorthand for it: SWERF. Sex Worker Exclusionary Radical Feminist. The core of the belief is that if there is a financial transaction taking place then it is not possible for the worker to give meaningful consent so all Johns are rapists. Thankfully I think this is a fringe viewpoint, you won't find too many people like this in the real world. They tend to stay on the Internet where they can be maximally amplified.
- yanderekko 5y ago>Thankfully I think this is a fringe viewpoint, you won't find too many people like this in the real world. The main problem is not SWERFs, it's that even sex-positive feminists tend to want to "normalize sex work" only from the production angle but not the consumption angle. This means that the rebuttal to SWERFs is not "sex work isn't exploitative", but "capitalism is exploitative and sex work is often the best option given the circumstances." Which leads to passivity at best towards attempts to shame/punish men who patronize sex workers.
- mc32 5y agoThat’s a great point you bring up. (diff attitudes toward supply side vs demand side from advocates) I have not looked into the attitudes toward sex work on the other side of the iron curtain. That’s an interesting topic. Undoubtedly it existed, but in the absence of capitalism perhaps it could not be considered exploitative.
- DarkWiiPlayer 5y agoThat thought can really be generalised; the problem I tend to have with feminism is how it conveniently forgets to address the male side of many problems until it's specifically pointed out, only to be acknowledged briefly and then put on a shelf again.
- DarkWiiPlayer 5y ago> The core of the belief is that if there is a financial transaction taking place then it is not possible for the worker to give meaningful consent so all Johns are rapists. I mean, it's a very narrow view, but I can kind of see where it's coming from. Of course, the obvious implication is that working for money now becomes "slavery" by the same reasoning. I think the problem is the assumption that prostitution would only ever happen as a last resort to stay financially afloat, and nobody would ever just choose it as their preferred way of earning an income; which time has shown, actually does happen, and more often than many might think.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI think legal sex work would be liberating - if it were possible to guarantee consent. But in practice, really consential sex work is too expensive, which is why there are criminals willing to force sex workers to work for a lot less and pocket most of the difference. And when prostitution is legal, the police can't really tell the difference. You can't ask the women, they've either been brainwashed or threatened enough. The johns don't want to know either, even though they are raping the girls every time. That's the background of Sweden's prostitution law. Assume exploitation, because you can't prove its absence.
- corty 5y agoThere is never the possibility of guaranteeing consent. Not even for sex (sans 'work'), not even in the presence of a notarized written agreement.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoI get your point. But there are better ways of assuring consent than paying the pimp...
- robocat 5y agoYou are making sweeping statements that sound unreal to me. I am in New Zealand where sex work is legal, and I know quite a few professional sex workers (disclaimer: not as a client but just random people that are somewhat open about it), and it is nothing like you have described. Without doubt the work has its risks, just different risks from other jobs (for example bar work is dangerous and minimum pay). However sex work pays extremely well: pay off a house mortgage in a handful of years rather than decades well (without needing a degree). It is not very good for your mental health from what I can tell (but hard to tease cause from effect here). That said, my social acquaintances don’t include the most at risk, the street workers doing dangerous tricks for a little money to get high. Those workers are definitely not saving for a home, and definitely are not getting the rewards for the risks.
- bayesian_horse 5y ago
- kwhitefoot 5y ago> he other that sex work was denigrating and exploitative (sex objects). All work is exploitative and the more so when the potential supply is larger than the demand. Look at the wages of office cleaners and supermarket shelf fillers.
- aikah 5y ago> All work is exploitative and the more so when the potential supply is larger than the demand. Look at the wages of office cleaners and supermarket shelf fillers. There is a difference between doing blowjobs for a "living" and flipping burgers, if you can't tell then, I can understand how you would make such an absurd point.
- handoflixue 5y agoWe already allow people to do blowjobs for a living, it just has to be pornography instead of prostitution. Why is it OK in one case, but not the other?
- aikah 5y ago> We already allow people to do blowjobs for a living, it just has to be pornography instead of prostitution. Why is it OK in one case, but not the other? Says you, who's we?
- DarkWiiPlayer 5y ago> There is a difference between doing blowjobs for a "living" and flipping burgers No, there really isn't. If one seems less appealing to you, just as it does to me, then that's fine because nobody is forcing us to do that kind of work. If, however, somebody else is completely fine with earning their money that way, why would we care or even tell them they aren't allowed to?
- dwaltrip 5y ago> If, however, somebody else is completely fine with earning their money that way, why would we care or even tell them they aren't allowed to? I'm pretty ignorant on this issue, so I may have this wrong. But my intuition is that sex work, on average and over the long term, is not positive for one's mental well being. Something about repeatably being so vulnerable and intimate with strangers who have little interest in your whole self. That said, even if I'm right, I'm not sure what the laws or policies should be.