9 ms·
> while also chronically underfunding schools Schools are not underfunded in the U.S., they waste money. Big difference.
by zozbot234 5y ago
> while also chronically underfunding schools
Schools are not underfunded in the U.S., they waste money. Big difference.
- John23832 5y agoSure. I can agree with that. The point being that, with the current schooling infrastructure, the amount of money needed to do what needs to be done isn't there.
- marcinzm 5y agoNo amount of money will fix a broken system from the inside since the money will go to those who broke the system in the first place.
- marcinzm 5y agoYup, from what I can tell the US has one of the highest per student spending amounts for primary and secondary schools.
- paulpauper 5y agoThat can be explained in part by compulsory schooling and individual education programs
- Ensorceled 5y agoAs with health care, the US spends near the top[1] per student and ranks among the worst for results. [1] https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd
- bradleyjg 5y agoBut we are top of the charts in percent overhead. USA! USA!
- dlp211 5y agoThe fundamental problem with these types of analysis is that it is the aggregate and average of a large mostly sparse country with a large population. Between Federalism, local & state politics, wealth concentration, and geographic constraint leads to some interesting and costly quirks to our school systems. It turns out that wealthy public school districts are extremely good and compete at the top of the world stage, and poor school districts are really, really, terrible and underperform on the world stage by a substantial margin.
- esyir 5y agoCould you support this with data of your own? I know that applies to university level education, but I've never seen the data for lower levels of education.
- larrymyers 5y agoFor what we expect of schools they are underfunded. Schools provide before and after care outside of normal hours, they provide all 3 meals to many students. Counseling, social services, health care ... it's not just teachers in the classroom. Now, if the US wanted to actually fix poverty and inequality dealing with the symptoms wouldn't roll down to the schools to deal with.
- Ensorceled 5y agoWe do all of that in Canada, for 3K per student less AND get much better results (at least on average).
- ipaddr 5y agoWhy do you think Canada gets a better results?
- Ensorceled 5y agoTo be clear, the results aren't great. We pay teachers more, we have pretty much no focus on elite athletics, less political mucking around in the actual education process.
- connectsnk 5y agoProbably can be attributed to huge asian and south asian immigrant population who put a very big emphasis on education in their families
- nick__m 5y agoYour theory doesn't explain Quebec scoring so high¹ in math in the 2018 PISA² test. https://www.schoolofpublicpolicy.sk.ca/research/publications/policy-brief/student-performance-in-pisa-2018.php https://www.schoolofpublicpolicy.sk.ca/research/publications... https://www.oecd.org/pisa/PISA-results_ENGLISH.png https://www.oecd.org/pisa/PISA-results_ENGLISH.png
- 5y ago
- kingsuper20 5y agoIt's remarkable how much the per capita, inflation corrected cost per pupil in California has gone up in 50 years. My own elementary school (not in CA), has double the amount of staff with the same pupil head count, plus I don't doubt that the salaries have risen faster than inflation and/or GDP improvements. OTOH, teachers were famously poorly paid in days of yore.
- j_walter 5y agoYou say paid poorly, but exactly how poorly? Usually the upfront pay was offset by a good pension, medical benefits and having the summer months off was a huge benefit. Teachers around here now make the average staring salary for a Bachelors Degree and still get the good benefits and time off.
- subsubzero 5y agoI have a friend that was a teacher in palo alto at a public school, she taught special ed and was making 86k, not exactly poor but I could imagine a teacher at middle school or high school making more.
- dragonwriter 5y ago>>It's remarkable how much the per capita, inflation corrected cost per pupil in California has gone up in 50 years. Is that adjusted for national or local price levels?
- ARandumGuy 5y agoFunding in U.S. schools is super unequal. Most school funding in the U.S. comes from local property tax. But if a district has a lot of poverty, then revenue from property tax is low. That means low funding for the local school, which lowers the quality of education for students, which makes it harder for the students to get out of poverty, which keeps the district's poverty level high. It's a self reinforcing cycle, which need to be fundamentally re-structured.
- xyzzyz 5y agoThis might have been true at some point in the past, but it is very much false now, and has been false for at least a decade or two. If local property tax revenues are low, the shortfall is made up for with state and federal funds. Just look at the data: worst performing urban schools often have more funding than better performing ones in rural areas or in smaller towns. If you don’t believe me, just show me a few examples, it shouldn’t be too hard to come up with, if the pattern is as strong and casually important as you suggest it is.
- coryrc 5y agoTo supplant your point: Detroit Public Schools per-pupil funding: $15,891 Average Michigan per-pupil funding: $13,457 https://www.michigancapitolconfidential.com/underfunded-detroit-is-states-15th-best-funded-larger-school-district https://www.michigancapitolconfidential.com/underfunded-detr...
- ARandumGuy 5y agoThe amount of local funding for public education varies wildly from state to state. In New Mexico in 2018, only 15% of public school revenue came from local sources. However, during the same year in Nebraska, that number is 53%. So yes, in some states differences in local property tax has a minimal effect on school funding. But in other states, the issue is still a significant issue. Source: https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cma?tid=4 https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cma?tid=4
- 5y ago
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Schools are not underfunded in the U.S Most first world countries are well above the US’s 5% GDP in public education expenditures; schools absolutely are underfunded in the US. It may also be unusually poorly administered, but this isn't like healthcare where US public spending is on par, as a share of GDP, with other developed countries despite doing far less with it.
- whatshisface 5y agoI am not sure if percent GDP the right metric to use, although perhaps dollars per student does not adjust for cost of living differences.
- aeternum 5y agoWe're also still using the same educational model we were in the 1700s. We know a lot more about learning now, and that model makes no sense. We know young kids learn through play yet we continually force them to learn through the equivalent of lectures. For older students that can learn through lectures, we insist on giving in-person lectures. This means that 99.9% of students are taught by sub-par lecturers. Highschool and college students are foolish to attend lectures person. Instead they should just watch the best in the world on opencourseware/youtube. Hands-on lab experience and group work is useful and difficult in a remote setting but a very small amount of HS/college time is spent on that. I'd argue pretty much all in-person HS/college time should be spent on that. We still attempt to teach the mechanics / tools first, like math and calc before the motivation. We do this even though we know that the human brain generally ignores information without utility. We should instead provide students a long-term goal they are interested in and introduce math / calc / physics as a means to achieve that goal.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoI tend to think they're underfunded and poorly administered with a lot of overhead.