3 ms·
The proof will be in the medals. The worst thing she could do for her cause is to actually win. If people see a sport where such transgender athletes are on t
by sandworm101 5y ago
The proof will be in the medals. The worst thing she could do for her cause is to actually win. If people see a sport where such transgender athletes are on the podium regularly and it is obvious they are doing better as a group, change will be demanded. Weightlifting looks to be that first test case but we were almost there before. Running faced a debate over allowing people with modified bodies to compete, but the so-called bladerunner disappeared from the scene and has yet to be replaced by another. The big question is the same as drugs: how much technology do we allow people to use? Are we committed to the idea of "natural" bodies in competition or do we allow technological modifications?
(Pistorius was born with feet. They were deformed feet and were surgically removed when he was very young. He used surgery to improve on his "natural" body. The prosthetic blades were then a second stage down the rabbit hole of technological augmentation.)
- gwd 5y agoI think the question with drugs is slightly different. Nobody cares how much vitamin C you take, because although making sure you're not vitamin C deficient has an advantage, at some point taking more doesn't help you at all; and if you take the maximum amount that your body will absorb, there are no health detriments. Same thing with creatine: taking creatine isn't "natural" in the sense that you'll end up with 2-3x as much in your system as you would "naturally"; but after a point, your body just stops using more; and if you take that amount, you won't have any health issues. With anabolic steroids however, if there is a "maximum amount that your body will absorb", it's far beyond what causes long-term health problems. This leads to a Prisoner's Dilemma type situation, where if most competitors are taking dose X, and one person takes dose X+1, that one person get an advantage; but if all competitors take does X+1, nobody has an advantage, but they all suffer health consequences. I don't inherently see a problem with any particular sport openly advertising that competitors may use up to dose X of any particular drug or steroid, where X has been reasonably shown to be a safe amount. The problem is, is it possible to test that only X has been taken, rather than X+1? If it's only possible to test that 0 (or a negligible amount) has been taken, then the only enforceable limit is 0; and an unenforced limit is effectively no limit at all.
- sandworm101 5y agoAll Olympic competitors sacrifice health for the sport. We are long past seeing them as healthy. The starvation diets in runners that lead to hormone shutdown are probably the best known example. Just as with many professional team sports, if you want to win you must accept lifelong consequences.