5 ms·
> sorry, it's 5:01 and the contract prohibits me from turning that screw, I'll be back Monday morning to do that for you Honest question. If you're paid hourly
by triceratops 5y ago
> sorry, it's 5:01 and the contract prohibits me from turning that screw, I'll be back Monday morning to do that for you
Honest question. If you're paid hourly and have job security, what's wrong with saying that? Pros don't work for free, right?
- mc32 5y agoSo if I'm not in a union (salaried or hourly) I can do someone a favor or someone can do me a favor. Union members get "ratted out" by others if they go "above and beyond". There is no flexibility.
- triceratops 5y ago> There is no flexibility. That's fair. The "I only sweep floors, if you want mopping it's another department" type of union inflexibility is terrible for productivity. But I think your scenario is an example of inflexibility that's completely warranted.
- jtdev 5y agoWhat you describe is a fallacy... it's more like: "I'm a heavy machinery operator, not a welder; if you need a weld, you'll need to requisition a welder."
- bluGill 5y agoI've been in places where you can't move your PC to the other side of your desk.
- dugmartin 5y agoA long time ago in grad school I had a administrative assistantship in the university's physical plant. My boss (basically the head of IT for the department) and I moved a couple of computers between buildings as they had actively used applications on them (this was before the web) and we couldn't wait for someone from building services come and do it. The next day I was in his office when we got a nice visit from the Teamsters steward flanked literally by two huge guys glaring at us. The steward told us not to do it again. He did back off when we told him we walked the computers between the buildings - if we would have drove them between buildings he said they would have filed a union grievance.
- zaarn 5y agoDepends on the Union and local work culture. Just like if you aren't part of a union (Amazon workers get "ratted out" by others if they "go on a bathroom break", as a hypothetical).
- themolecularman 5y agoI think it's more the fact that there aren't alternative options. Other comments have already explored how America has a "union monopoly" system for lack of a better term: where unions exist, the labor pool that is non-union is often extinguished. > what's wrong with saying that? If the alleged screw is flooding your home and you're on the phone with a contractor who says "it'll be Monday morning", it's safe to assume that the contractor feels safe because there's no competition out there that will come out to finish the job due to the union monopoly or other rules/regulations that the unions have established to make them the only turn screwers. Unions in the United States gained a bad rap from things like this, and I think that's what the OP's intent was with their comment.
- adriancr 5y ago> If the alleged screw is flooding your home and you're on the phone with a contractor who says "it'll be Monday morning", Free market would dictate you say back: "double pay" or hire another contractor.
- svieira 5y agoWhich you can't do because the rates are established in law and the only people who are allowed to do the job are people with a certificate that is only provided by the union. Regulatory capture happens with unions as well as with bosses.
- adriancr 5y agoWho told you that?, sources? Overtime pay is a thing everywhere including union jobs. I'm based in Europe and i get overtime pay if I'm forced to work late/weekends. One of the nice things of unions everywhere. If i dont want to or cant work late, there are colleagues that will jump at 150% pay rate. Companies can hire contractors at any point but these expect much higher wages to deal with the almost no protections and doing their own taxes. Otherwise employer could hire a second shift as they do with manufacturing and pay normal wage there. There is no such thing as union certificate or things of the sort. Union is there just to negotiate basic contract applied company wide and make sure you are not abused. Working in software.
- jdavis703 5y agoI’ve worked in a union shop before, and that’s not how it worked. When push came to shove people would work overtime (and actually be paid for it!). I remember one department was under intense pressure for months, and the people there were literally running around to get their jobs done.
- triceratops 5y agoThat was my point. Union contracts generally have an overtime clause. If they don't then saying "See you Monday" a completely rational thing to do.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]