> Well the example you gave is bad feedback > the feedback that sparked this discussion does seem like useful feedback The former was a summary of the latter.

> Well the example you gave is bad feedback > the feedback that sparked this discussion does seem like useful feedback The former was a summary of the latter. The "feedback" we're talking about gave no actual information about what the person thinks is wrong with TFA, it just said that TFA's author is ignorant and maybe look at XYZ.