2 ms·
I agree that's the greatest weakness in theory. But in practice that's extremely unlikely -- because there's always a significant proportion of the population
by crazygringo 5y ago
I agree that's the greatest weakness in theory.
But in practice that's extremely unlikely -- because there's always a significant proportion of the population that isn't tribalistic (or religious, in your case) the fourth candidate will tend to receive a decent proportion of first-place votes.
Alternatives have their own problems as well, where approval voting doesn't let you specify intensity of preference, or systems that let you granularly specify intensity of preference are not only too complicated for voters to understand, but also fairly arbitrary in how they compare intensities.
- dllthomas 5y ago> But in practice that's extremely unlikely I don't think that's true at all. I agree that I picked a particularly extreme example to make the issue clear, but fundamentally IRV is a statement that the compromise we choose must be the first choice of a large portion of the population. I think that is a bad strategy, and situations where it picks poorly won't be uncommon.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]