7 ms·
I think sports categories should be chromosome strings. "XX division", "XY world record". "XXY 400 m finals", "XYY long jump trials", ... Gender identity does
by kazinator 5y ago
I think sports categories should be chromosome strings.
"XX division", "XY world record". "XXY 400 m finals", "XYY long jump trials", ...
Gender identity doesn't factor into it at all; the words "man", "woman" should not be used.
Problem solved; you don't get to wedge yourself into competition with XX persons if you're XY.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hashmymustache 5y agoSo the XX group on anabolic steroids won’t be an issue?
- whatshisface 5y agoIt might be better to have hormone classes in sports the way boxing has weight classes. You could have Mike Tyson class all the way through Betty White class, and as a side benefit you'd be able to put women's sports teams in with appropriately matched men. As another side benefit a lot of people who were simply born with the wrong stuff to compete could rise to the top of their class by hard work. Since there's not that much value in "gene grading" people, when all the heroism comes from training and dedication, getting away from the birth lottery sports system could be helpful to the sports documentary industry, along with the human soul. ;)
- Zababa 5y agoHave classes for everything, this way everyone is in their own special class and everyone is a world champion. This way everyone will be happy right? /s
- monstreums 5y agoHave classes for nothing, this way we can ignore those emaciated wannabes like Mayweather and Pacquiao and focus our attentions on the one true world champion of boxing, the man who has the bulk to back it. Classes are only there to give awards to inferior athletes for no reason right? /s
- zqna 5y agoLooking forward to Nerd Olympics
- tasogare 5y agoWhich percentage of those three letters categories are in the population? Very few. And competitive athletes in them? Probably epsilon. The man and woman categories worked without issue for centuries, the whole problem is self-inflected.
- slg 5y agoAt what levels would this apply? Would we actually blood test 14 year olds? What about trans men who where assigned female at birth? Are they allowed to take testosterone and still compete against XX women?
- stOneskull 5y agowhy not trans athletics? a separate group.
- kbelder 5y agoPopulated with transwomen and transmen? I suspect that the same problem would surface. It would be amusing though, because it would be a category where all the women would be beating all the men at weightlifting.
- stOneskull 5y agotransmen vs transmen, transwomen vs transwomen
- leephillips 5y agoI think if the 14 year olds are entering an olympic event they would be blood-tested as a matter of routine, no? I don’t know what this “assigned female” phrase means, can you explain? And no, I’m pretty sure shooting up testosterone is a no-no in the Olympics.
- wolfgang42 5y ago“Assigned female”[0] just means that their original birth certificate has an ‘F’ in the sex field, normally assigned based on observed physical characteristics. It also generally implies that everyone assumed this was correct (with the associated gender roles etc) until the person began expressing a gender identity independently—in this case a different one, though for most people they tend to be the same. In this case 'slg is also using it to imply that the person’s natural physical characteristics also match their assigned sex. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_assignment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sex_assignment
- wolfgang42 5y agoThat seems like it introduces more problems than it solves; genetic essentialism as a solution to debates about gender tends to be an approach that nobody agrees with. Now you still have the same concerns about people using hormones, plus: - intersex people whose phenotype and genotype don’t match (putting them in the “wrong” category) - chimeric people who belong in different categories depending on which part of their body you sample - probably other edge cases I’m not thinking of. If your goal is just to put people into categories, it’s probably a lot less controversial to split them based on if their earlobe is attached and whether they can curl their tongue.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- crooked-v 5y agoHave you considered the effects of androgen insensitivity syndrome? Chromosomes don't always neatly map to physical traits.
- beerandt 5y agoHave you considered that forcing the abnormal to be included with the normal renders both terms meaningless?
- crooked-v 5y agoThis categorization scheme would specifically include the 'abnormal' and the 'normal' together based entirely on chromosomes.
- cudgy 5y agoNo matter what classification is used, there will be variations. However, using a deterministic criteria reduces incentive to game the system. More importantly, it reduces (for example) the pressure on participants to change their sexual identity to improve their competition level in a sport or at the least give the impression that the change was made for competitive reasons.
- beerandt 5y agoMy point is that if something is "different" , forcing others to label that thing as "not-different" isn't a productive battle. Others will just now need a new way to describe it, because to them, the original label is now meaningless in it's classic sense, to them. For example we've gone from: (some male terms I apparently can't use anymore) to transwoman to ciswoman to biological woman. And in every case the transwomen demands to be included in the "new" category, and everyone else has to come up with another term to differentiate.
- kazinator 5y agoThe point isn't to line up with physical traits, but to prevent issues such as some XY beefcake who identified as a man for 35 years using gender politics to impose perself into the XX category. This doesn't replace trait-based subcategorization. E.g. the category XX wrestling still has weight classes.
- yerwhat01010 5y agoSex chromosome variants aren't separate sexes. You're male, and develop a male body producing male gametes, if you have a Y chromosome: * X – Female * XX – Female * XXY – Male * XY – Male * XYY – Male * XXXY – Male https://colinwright.substack.com/p/sex-chromosome-variants-are-not-their https://colinwright.substack.com/p/sex-chromosome-variants-a...
- kuschku 5y agoXY but defect on the SRY region: female XX with SRY region on one of the X: Male XY with androgen insensitivity: female There's a lot more of a spectrum than you'd think. Many of the cis female athletes currently winning in the olympics, e.g. caster semenya, have significantly higher testosterone levels than would be legal for trans female athletes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]