3 ms·
I guess I disagree that (1) would be especially alarming. Mishandling of lab samples occurs all the time (even with good precautions), everyone knows this, and
by zozbot234 5y ago
I guess I disagree that (1) would be especially alarming. Mishandling of lab samples occurs all the time (even with good precautions), everyone knows this, and this is actually an excellent reason to be all the more cautious about whether GoF research should be allowed. Zoonotics are also a fact of life. Ultimately, it comes down to what one's priors are re: what actually happened in this case; it doesn't really matter much either way.
- 22c 5y agoYou seem be shifting the goal posts. Do you find it fishy that these early samples were not fully sequenced, and that the parts that were sequenced were later deleted?
- tptacek 5y agoMishandling of novel or virulent pathogens that cause widespread outbreaks do not in fact occur all the time. It's not hard to see why it matters how C19 happened: if it was in fact a lab leak, that would suggest strongly that it's problematic to site this kind of research in densely populated areas (contra the stereotypes, Wuhan, "the Chicago of China", is a densely populated metropolis). Had novel coronavirus research been centered in Casper, Wyoming, and an outbreak occurred there, we wouldn't much have to wonder where the virus came from.