2 ms·
Yes, approval voting is a simpler system that also tends to reward moderate or "compromise" candidates.
by zozbot234 5y ago
Yes, approval voting is a simpler system that also tends to reward moderate or "compromise" candidates.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> approval voting is a simpler system that also tends to reward moderate or "compromise" candidates I don't have a strong preference between approval and RCV. But I think people closer to politics would. Being able to "be behind" one candidate is a meaningful promoter of civic engagement; forcing that decision is deeply entrenched in our politics. That makes approval voting a tougher sell for implementation than RCV. Given how much better RCV and approval voting are than FPTP, it seems sensible to go with RCV.
- zozbot234 5y agoImplementation is actually a lot simpler. With approval voting, there is no change to the physical paper ballot; you just allow the voter to punch multiple holes on a single ballot, to represent the candidates she "approves" of.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Implementation is actually a lot simpler That's not the phase of implementation that's difficult with any of these systems. It's getting the rules changed. Approval voting changes civic engagement in a fundamental way. (It also has much less real-world data behind it.)
- ClayShentrup 5y ago> That makes approval voting a tougher sell for implementation than RCV. Approval voting was passed by a 2-1 landslide majority in both Fargo and St Louis. Public opinion research by the Center for Election Science shows random American voters are much more supportive of approval voting than IRV, relative to the status quo. By a huge margin.