3 ms·
> I don’t like tank [sic] choice voting because it can result in someone with fewer first place votes than the first or second candidate to win if the condition
by AnimalMuppet 5y ago
> I don’t like tank [sic] choice voting because it can result in someone with fewer first place votes than the first or second candidate to win if the conditions are right.
Why do you consider that the "wrong" outcome?
- mc32 5y agoBecause the way people understand it is that if candidate #1 doesn't win, then candidate #2 would win, maybe candidate #3, but not candidate #5. And people are often disappointed to learn that the first, second or third, 1st choice vote-getters are not the winners but rather the #1 3rd, 4th, or 5th choice vote getter can end up winning (again because people think they HAVE to cast all votes --which obviously they don't, but that enables the possibility of the throwaway candidate winning)
- dragonwriter 5y agoThe rest of the comment seems to explain that the problem is that poorly considered candidates win because people don't give as much care below the top spot in a wide pool of candidates: > We’ve seen surprise results where an obscure candidate has won when too many top choices split the first choice votes and someone relegated to the floor vacuums up all the throwaway votes (people think they have to “spend” all their votes) I think its an understandable concern under any single round ranked-ballots method where you arr likely to have a large pool of cnadidates. But it can be simply remedied with a two-round system using the same method iterated to select a manageable pool of candidates (possibly gating in the top couple first-place vote getters even if they otherwise wouldn’t be in the top) for the runoff round, which still uses the same ranked-ballots method with more confidence that all the candidates have been vetted because there is a narrower field. This keeps the integrity of whatever ranked-ballots method is chosen while avoiding the (small, but not nonexistent) risk of winning by flying under the radar.