4 ms·
There's no evidence in the parent, just the opinions of a few political actors. > radicals have already successfully overtaken Western universities Ironically
by wolverine876 5y ago
There's no evidence in the parent, just the opinions of a few political actors.
> radicals have already successfully overtaken Western universities
Ironically, this uses techniques from the OP. It's an emotional appeal - calling people radicals, catastrophizing, etc. - but there's no evidence and really no information. Hyperbole eliminates information; it's like screaming 'we're all going to die!'.
- sreque 5y agoIf you don't consider these eyewitness accounts as evidence, then I can only assume you have your blinders on. It is very important to note that these people you dismiss as "political actors" were historically apolitical; they weren't active at all in politics, and many even identified more as liberals or democrats. They only became more active as they bore personal witness to the evil ideologies being perpetuated in our society. Bari Weiss and Jordan Peterson, two historically liberal, well-educated people, discuss what they consider far and away to be the greatest threat to Western Civilization. and guess what? It's not Trump. It's not white supremacists. It's not racism. It's not January 6 rioters. It's not people who refuse to get COVID vaccines. It's not global warming. It's not even China or Russia or Islamic terrorism. It is the self-destruction of our culture at the hands of leftist ideologues that seek its destruction in order to replace it with a new, far worse culture. I could send you a ton more links with evidence, but I have a feeling you would find a reason to dismiss all of them: * https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-neo-marxist-takeover-of-our-universities https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-neo-marxist-takeover... "The domination of US universities by the left, particularly in the humanities and social sciences, is well documented. In 2016 a survey carried out by Econ Journal Watch looked at the voter registration of faculty members at 40 leading US universities in the fields of economics, history, law, psychology and journalism/communications. It found that Democrats outnumber Republicans by an average of 11.5 to one. In psychology, the ratio is 17.4 to one; in history, 33.5 to one." * https://fcpp.org/2020/11/27/how-marxists-take-over-and-what-to-do-about-it/ https://fcpp.org/2020/11/27/how-marxists-take-over-and-what-... * https://www.amazon.com/Professors-Most-Dangerous-Academics-America/dp/1596985259/ https://www.amazon.com/Professors-Most-Dangerous-Academics-A...
- wolverine876 5y ago> If you don't consider these eyewitness accounts as evidence, then I can only assume you have your blinders on. Not only does that violate HN guidelines, and is irrational and ignorant, it's just propaganda against me. Have a nice day.
- sreque 5y agoI'm pretty sure courts consider eyewitness accounts as evidence, and rightly so. In what universe is it not considered evidence? Note there is a difference between evidence and incontrovertible proof. I'm starting to think when you say "propaganda" you mean "anything I don't think is true or am unwilling to investigate further for myself."
- wolverine876 5y agoSadly, you didn't read my comment. I said 'have a nice day', and here you are attacking someone. That will never make you feel good. Really, do something positive and constructive. Go help an elderly person across the street. Genuinely, I hope you have a nice day. I've gotta go do something creative and constructive myself.
- sreque 5y agoI read your comment, including the "have a nice day." However, You don't get to dictate my actions, including what I decide is a good use of my time, or how I behave in a public forum. Also, I'm not attacking you. I'm pointing out things you are uncomfortable with and unwilling to look at critically. That is far from attacking you.
- blindmute 5y agoIf eyewitness accounts are not evidence, what would pass as evidence to you? Anyone with children in public school has seen this. Do you really need a peer reviewed study on every piece of information to form a worldview?
- wolverine876 5y ago> If eyewitness accounts are not evidence What a few people in the whole country say is necessarily credible and is evidence of a widespread trend? Wow. Do you know what you can find people saying, especially on the Internet? It's surprising that people, especially on HN where evidence is commonplace, and especially in a discussion on propaganda, are so triggered by that. Note that almost nobody in this thread is discussing the facts of the original claim, they all are trying to change the subject to me. > Anyone with children in public school has seen this. What I read is, 'I'm so sure that I haven't even looked for or at evidence.' It's not a good sign. Fact and reason are the difference between burning witches at the stake on one hand, and justice, fairness, truth, law, and science on the other.
- blindmute 5y ago> What I read is, 'I'm so sure that I haven't even looked for or at evidence.' It's not a good sign. What you should read is that there is so much obvious evidence, easily available, that asking for more of it can only be interpreted as bad faith. I am certain that there is no evidence that fits your standard, because short of "Study: Schools taken over by radicals" you would not accept it. A scientific study like this would never be funded, even if this were a question for science (it isn't), for many reasons. A google search of the relevant terms would turn up dozens of egregious instances. Have you looked?