4 ms·
> indoctrination and propaganda happening in US education What evidence do you have that it is happening and on what scale? My teachers, all that I recall, ne
by wolverine876 5y ago
> indoctrination and propaganda happening in US education
What evidence do you have that it is happening and on what scale?
My teachers, all that I recall, never presented any opinion or perspective as truth. It was always about thinking critically for ourselves. If, for example, they presented a well-established view on the sinking of the Maine, it was as material for our analysis and evaluation.
- sreque 5y agoThe evidence that radicals have already successfully overtaken Western universities is overwhelming, and the evidence that these radicals are in the process of taking over secondary education is also readily available for anyone who is interested. If you are actually looking for some eyewitness accounts, Jordan Peterson has many podcasts where he interviews specific people that have experienced the ideological takeover themselves, including: * Yeonmi Park: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yqa-SdJtT4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yqa-SdJtT4 * Dr. Rima Azar: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIw8mH7ZpFY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cIw8mH7ZpFY * Bret Weinstein: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2O_gW4VWZ5c https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2O_gW4VWZ5c He has also interviewed one person who lost his job fighting the takeover in high school: * Paul Rossi: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysQBegyQP8A https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysQBegyQP8A He's also interviewed a self-identified liberal and former employee of New York Times that witnessed the takeover at the Times. Starting at minute 8 the conversation diverges into talking about her experience at University. * Bari Weiss: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFTA9MJZ4KY&t=12s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tFTA9MJZ4KY&t=12s Bari Weiss says it herself in this podcast, loosely quoted since I don't remember it exactly: If you as a liberal can't see the danger in what is happening, then you have your blinders on. I would say the same holds true of people who can't see the takeover in education, which is already mostly complete. Edit: I found the Bari Weiss quote at 43:06: "I have to be honest. At this point, if one can't see the way that this language has been hijacked and used as a kind of trojan horse strategy to smuggle in a hardened, zero-sum identity politics view of the world, to smuggle in a view of the world in which we have collective guilt or collective innocence literally based on the circumstances of our birth, that smuggle in a deeply anti-capitalist position, to smuggle in essentially a leftist illiberalism, then, I'm sorry. You have blinders on! The evidence is so overwhelming at this point.... I think it's because admitting that's true, is extremely psychologically scary, and socially scary, if you are a liberal."
- wolverine876 5y agoThere's no evidence in the parent, just the opinions of a few political actors. > radicals have already successfully overtaken Western universities Ironically, this uses techniques from the OP. It's an emotional appeal - calling people radicals, catastrophizing, etc. - but there's no evidence and really no information. Hyperbole eliminates information; it's like screaming 'we're all going to die!'.
- sreque 5y agoIf you don't consider these eyewitness accounts as evidence, then I can only assume you have your blinders on. It is very important to note that these people you dismiss as "political actors" were historically apolitical; they weren't active at all in politics, and many even identified more as liberals or democrats. They only became more active as they bore personal witness to the evil ideologies being perpetuated in our society. Bari Weiss and Jordan Peterson, two historically liberal, well-educated people, discuss what they consider far and away to be the greatest threat to Western Civilization. and guess what? It's not Trump. It's not white supremacists. It's not racism. It's not January 6 rioters. It's not people who refuse to get COVID vaccines. It's not global warming. It's not even China or Russia or Islamic terrorism. It is the self-destruction of our culture at the hands of leftist ideologues that seek its destruction in order to replace it with a new, far worse culture. I could send you a ton more links with evidence, but I have a feeling you would find a reason to dismiss all of them: * https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-neo-marxist-takeover-of-our-universities https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/the-neo-marxist-takeover... "The domination of US universities by the left, particularly in the humanities and social sciences, is well documented. In 2016 a survey carried out by Econ Journal Watch looked at the voter registration of faculty members at 40 leading US universities in the fields of economics, history, law, psychology and journalism/communications. It found that Democrats outnumber Republicans by an average of 11.5 to one. In psychology, the ratio is 17.4 to one; in history, 33.5 to one." * https://fcpp.org/2020/11/27/how-marxists-take-over-and-what-to-do-about-it/ https://fcpp.org/2020/11/27/how-marxists-take-over-and-what-... * https://www.amazon.com/Professors-Most-Dangerous-Academics-America/dp/1596985259/ https://www.amazon.com/Professors-Most-Dangerous-Academics-A...
- akomtu 5y agoThat's a real thing, though. In fact, some legislatures are so concerned that they've started passing laws prohibiting propaganda. Example is the recent HB3979 bill: https://legiscan.com/TX/text/HB3979/id/2339637 https://legiscan.com/TX/text/HB3979/id/2339637
- dragonwriter 5y ago> In fact, some legislatures are so concerned that they've started passing laws prohibiting propaganda. Example is the recent HB3979 bill But that law: (1) Nowhere prohibits propaganda, by name or in effect, (2) mandates teaching propaganda, and specifically teaching various propaganda documents, opinion/analysis works, and campaign presentations (the Federalist Papers, Democracy in America, the first Lincoln-Douglas debate) ahistorically as “founding documents of the United States” rather than as propaganda, controversial opinion, etc. It does explicitly prohibit policies mandating teaching current events, though. But not propaganda.
- jollybean 5y agoSo I would disagree with both of those points. For part 2) it says they 'must teach those foundational concepts and supporting documents' (i.e. Constitution) but it doesn't say how. I'm not sure if that counts as 'must teach propaganda'. For part 1) The Boards are prohibited from requiring teachers to teach current events via an ideological nature, but it does not prohibit teachers from teaching anything - rather they must teach the subject from a variety of viewpoints without taking sides. "(2) teachers who choose to discuss current events or widely debated and currently controversial issues of public policy or social affairs shall, to the best of their ability, strive to explore such issues from diverse and contending perspectives without giving deference to any one perspective;" And prohibiting things like giving credit for activist projects etc.. If parents want to get their kids involved in activism, that's perfectly fine but I don't think that's the school's job. Honestly, I don't like that we feel such a document needs to exist, but I think it's pretty fair, neutral and civic. As a parent, I would be happy if this were already the 'policy' at my school board.
- wolverine876 5y ago
- seertaak 5y agoThere are slides circulating on Twitter, apparently snapped during presentations given to educators in the context of diversity training, exhorting viewers to understand, say, punctuality as a manifestation of white supremacy. Set aside for a moment the very fair questions one can ask about the trustworthiness of these images. Ignore for now whether this was shown to 5 or 5000 eductors, etc. Let's just assume such instructions were in fact given to educators on some non-negligible scale. Would that be evidence enough for you?
- wolverine876 5y ago> Let's just assume such instructions were in fact given to educators on some non-negligible scale. IMHO, and pertinent to the OP: That is out of textbook of how mis- and disinformation impacts human thinking: Observe something emotionally provocative and follow the urge to dive in, regardless of the reality: 'What if it's true???" I've trained myself not to do it. I'm always interested in valuable, credible information. (And to be clear, it's not your job to educate me - that's my job - but it is your job to backup what you say.) > slides circulating on Twitter Is there any place where amount of propaganda is greater, in the history of the world, than on social media such as Twitter? It must be orders of magnitude beyond anything ever. Serious question: Why are you reading it? It's like digging through a garbage dump for coins.
- nescioquid 5y agoYou seem to deny there is any propaganda or indoctrination happening in U.S. education. A commenter asked what it would take to change your mind, and offers a hypothetical scenario as a test (which may have some basis in reality, but excludes that from consideration), and you refused to consider it. Do you think there is any sort of evidence, if demonstrated adequately, that would change your mind? What sort of evidence would be sufficient?
- wolverine876 5y agoI'm not defending myself against baseless allegations, if that's what you are seeking. They made a claim, not me. Let's see some evidence or it's just, effectively, propaganda. Anybody can say anything without evidence.