5 ms·
What happened to the lightning network? (Serious question, I am out of the loop.)
by andai 5y ago
What happened to the lightning network? (Serious question, I am out of the loop.)
- thesausageking 5y agoIt launched, is usable in most wallets, and is starting to get adoption. It's going to be a key piece of the recently passed legislation in El Salvador which makes Bitcoin legal tender.
- hypnotist 5y agoEl Salvador not Colombia
- thesausageking 5y agoYes. Not sure why I wrote Colombia. Thx.
- simias 5y agoUsing a closed, centralized implementation that doesn't accept third party nodes. The use of bitcoin is pure marketing, it's just MySQL with extra steps.
- delaaxe 5y agoSource?
- lawn 5y agoThey will be using Strike, which is a custodial wallet.
- WanderPanda 5y agoWait, it does not allow third party nodes? What is my Raspberry Pi right next to me doing? Just pretending to be a Lightning Node?
- cmckn 5y agoParent is referring to El Salvador's proposed usage, not the wider lightning network.
- krick 5y agoThis is interesting. Obviously, I heard about the whole "El Salvador something something Bitcoin" deal, but am completely unaware of the actual situation. Can somebody point me in the direction of some nice writeup explaining these details? I can only vaguely imagine how one can take Bitcoin and make it essentially an extension of SWIFT, and struggle to clearly visualize what the implications of this are.
- pixelperfect 5y agoThe legislation that made Bitcoin legal tender in El Salvador does not legislate the use of Strike. Businesses can use whatever system they want, as long as they can accept payment in Bitcoin. Strike is providing a service that allows any business to take Bitcoin lightning payments and have them automatically converted to dollars, for businesses that do not want to hold Bitcoin. It's not fair to just call this a "sql database" because it's connected to an open payment network and the customer can use whatever means they want to pay the business, even if the business decides to just uses Strike.
- counternotions 5y agoFrom Strike CEO Jack Maller [1]: Let’s walk through a user story. I want to send $1,000 to a friend of mine in El Salvador: * When I initiate the $1,000 payment, Strike debits my existing USD balance. * Strike then automatically converts my $1,000 to bitcoins ready for use in its infrastructure using its real-time automated risk management and trading infrastructure. * Strike then moves the bitcoins across the Gulf of Mexico where it arrives in our Central American infrastructure in less than a second and for no cost. * Strike then takes the bitcoins and automatically converts them back into USDT (synthetic digital dollar known as Tether) using its real-time automated risk management and trading infrastructure. * Strike then credits the existing user with the USDT to their Strike account. [1] https://jimmymow.medium.com/announcing-strike-global-2392b908f611 https://jimmymow.medium.com/announcing-strike-global-2392b90...
- noxer 5y agoThere is no bitcoin needed for this at all its does not even move on the chain for the transfer. Both sides are Strike entities all this does is use bitcoin as a bridge for USD to USD which is completely pointless as both sides are USD. You could just buy USDT (or another stabelcoin) and send it there. Its a different story if there is actually a switch in currency needed. There is this famous and from bitcoin people often hated company called Ripple that specializes on cross-border settlement using crypto as a bridge currency. For that however the crypto must be actually moved and be sold locally for the local currency. And for that to work without risk due to volatility it must be fast. Hence they use XRP (4 sec) instead of bitcoin (10+ min). They call it ODL (On-Demand Liquidity). See https://ripple.com/ripplenet/on-demand-liquidity/ https://ripple.com/ripplenet/on-demand-liquidity/
- doomroot 5y agoThe ceo of strike said they are continually promoting that banks and businesses in the El Salvador operate their own lightning network nodes & not to solely rely on them. Only the government’s official (but optional) app will be a wrapper around strike.
- espadrine 5y agoI am puzzled by one thorn it is intended to solve. In the case of merchant/customer interactions, the LN channel blocks customer funds from their balance, but they will never receive money from the merchant. So that balance will be sent to the merchant, payment by payment. Not only does that block funds for the customer (which wants to reduce those, to avoid blocking too much, but that reduces the number of payments that can be made off-chain), but it also blocks the merchant’s reception of those payments: the merchant wants to be able to spend it soon, but it can only spend it on-chain. That is compounded by the fact that most merchant/customer interactions are rare one-offs in the real world. I just don’t buy stamps every day. LN channels are only most useful when the two parties exchange money bidirectionally on average.
- doomroot 5y agoIt’s an ongoing problem for sure, but the simple answer is users maintaining multiple well connected channels. It’s very common on lightning to pay liquidity providers to balance your channels to you. Lightning Labs has a service called loop where you can pay them an onchain transaction and it will make a lightning network payment to your channel for that amount, thus giving you more spend liquidity. Loop is sweet cause it does this in a non custodial way, look into it.
- xwolfi 5y agoEl Salvador, the military dictatorship that managed to make western dreamer hype it like a shitcoin...
- lottin 5y agoApparently it has serious design flaws that compromise its security and performance.
- kemonocode 5y agoIt exists, and it very much works [0] but it has yet to reach the massive levels of adoption people would have expected by now. Simple as that. [0] https://1ml.com/ https://1ml.com/
- WanderPanda 5y agoAfaik it is still considered #reckless to put bigger amounts on your lightning node and at least the "lnd" implementation seems to be in "beta" (according to their Github releases). Idk about the roadmap for a solid, production ready version is. But in this case safe seems to be better than sorry
- Taek 5y agoLightning network more or less failed to live up to the hype. Problems like routing complexity, liquidity, and a lack of on-chain space to open and close channels have delayed/limited its impact.
- SnowProblem 5y agoTo expand on this, to receive money over Lightning, you need someone else to lock up their bitcoins for you. This is called inbound liquidity, and the problem of users getting inbound liquidity is no joke. Lightning Labs recently launched Lightning Pool to help with this, but fees range from 5% to 25%. Uncompetitive. If you think about it too, it makes sense, because anyone locking up their bitcoins for others should expect a several % return, or else they would loan it out at similar rates. Current Lightning wallets are basically giving their users inbound liquidity for free using VC funds, but is this honestly sustainable? There are other problems with Lightning, like the requirement to be online to receive payments, watchtowers, UX complexity of channels. Some of these are solvable through centralization. But that is why you'll hear people say Lightning recreate the banking model, because realistically that looks like the only way it could work. Oddly, this was all pointed out by many people over the years, but Lightning seems to get endless forgiveness in its inability to deliver, because it is BTC's only hope to maintain the peer-to-peer cash narrative.
- noxer 5y agoThe looking up of liquidity is the whole reason LN can not scale or be cheap ever. Today people in crypto may be willing to look up bitcoins they hold long term anyway. But in the real world this would be dead and trapped capital it doesn't work for you and you cant even use it to quickly buy something an take advantage of a market situation. The only reason why someone would look up capital like that if is it makes money. So people who use someone else locked up bitcoins have to pay. This makes LN impossible to be cheap. You literally lend money to send money to someone. Its complete absurd. And as you said to make this more efficient large centralized pools are created so there will be a monopoly or oligopoly for lending, hows that gonna be good for the fees. LN was dead before they started coding it.
- RazTeve 5y agoits maturing, works pretty well already, but surely patience helps with emergent tech
- uncletammy 5y agoIn order to get money on and off lightning network, you still need to make on-chain BTC transactions. Meanwhile, the BTC devs have intentionally changed the network so that it's expensive to make on-chain transactions. From this you can probably figure out why lightning network failed.