9 ms·
> a promise to make landlords whole while giving renters a clean slate I feel a little torn: renters who may have lost their jobs, being able to get their head
by JKCalhoun 5y ago
> a promise to make landlords whole while giving renters a clean slate
I feel a little torn: renters who may have lost their jobs, being able to get their heads above water seems to be a good thing. Bailing out the landlords seems to me to be less of a good thing.
In a world that seems increasingly to tilt in favor of the fortunate (those owning the land) and offers little to the unfortunate (the renters) my desire for justice wants the scale to tip the other direction at least once in a while.
Am I a bad person?
- emodendroket 5y agoI do find the rush to make landlords whole a little strange. Isn’t the concept here that you’re making a speculative investment and the risk is what justifies the profit?
- dmitrygr 5y agoYes but as a landlord I am supposed to be able to remove a non-paying tenant. They took away that ability, so now landlord HAD TO provide free housing to someone while still making mortgage payments.
- lucian1900 5y agoOr default on the mortgage. You’re not proving housing, you’re preventing people from having housing unless they pay you. When housing wasn’t a speculative investment it was far cheaper and far fewer people were forced to rent to make someone else money for no labour.
- dmitrygr 5y agoSo you've never heard of duplexes? Default -> homeless
- _-david-_ 5y agoSome landlords rent out a room in their own house they live in. If they stopped renting there would be no additional housing available.
- lucian1900 5y agoCouldn’t those that are currently such landlords have been incentivised to purchase smaller homes, making more large ones available? Or alternatively, some large homes could be subdivided. Why should tenants pay for the greed of landlords? They get paid for doing nothing, the least they could do is bear their own risks.
- dmitrygr 5y agoOk, but how do we handle this until we completely remake the world in precisely the way that lucian1900 thinks it should be?
- lucian1900 5y agoI’m just pointing out that landlords are exploiting tenants and other arrangements are possible and have existed. Building social housing, removing incentives for buy-to-rent, taxing second homes and capping rents to a fraction of minimum wage are all measures that can be introduced gradually on the way to de-commodifying housing.
- _-david-_ 5y agoThey may not have bought a smaller house. Sometimes people buy a larger house because they have kids. When their kids move out they may rent out the rooms. While moving to a smaller place may make good financial sense in some ways, some people don't like to move. They like their neighborhood and house and all. You just sit on your computer programming or whatever you do. That is just getting paid for typing which is not real work. Maybe you should stop being greedy and just type for free.
- lucian1900 5y ago
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe government changed the rules of the investment, though. Before the eviction moratorium, landlords could at least predict the maximum amount of rent they would lose due to non-payment before they could evict someone and find new tenants. The moratorium removed that option, changing the risk profile dramatically without warning. That’s the issue.
- scotuswroteus 5y agoTo others, "the issue" is that the rules of investment include commoditizing homes while militarizing police responses to vagrancy and loitering. IMHO, bailing out all landlords with the budget surplus makes sense for a different reason: to ensure that the next time the government needs to do something like this, given the ever escalating financial and fiscal emergency in which a majority of us find ourselves, they know that the government will figure out a make good on the other end.
- __blockcipher__ 5y agoIt really scares me that this even needs to be explained to people. The government is outright stealing from landlords. They literally made it illegal (while also not passing an actual law, as far as I know [which is how every COVID restriction worked as well]) to evict somebody. So many people have this juvenile notion of what a landlord is, too. They seem to think the only type of landlord is a mega-tycoon that owns hundreds of properties. Don't get me wrong, I am against all forms of theft so it's still wrong to steal from them, but it makes it a lot more apparent how wrong it is when you're stealing from the old Grandma that has 1 or 2 extra properties that she rents out.
- emodendroket 5y agoIf a change in the law causes a stock I own to crater in value, is the government “outright stealing from” me?
- nybble41 5y agoThat obviously depends on what the change was. If the business of the company in question was predicated on selling services to the government and the law changes such that they no longer require the company's services, then no, that is not stealing from you. If the change in the law is that the company is henceforth required to provide service without payment then yes, absolutely, that is stealing from you. The government doesn't owe you a particular market price, but when they interfere with your perfectly voluntary private business dealings (or just outright take your stuff for public use without just compensation, which is basically what happened here) that is a clear-cut example of theft.
- treeman79 5y agoThe state caused the harm to landlords. So it can be argued the state is responsible for the problem. Imagine your neighbor sneezes. So the bank sends thugs to take steak your rent money. Then sending police to take your house for non payment. All the while blaming you as the problem. At some point the absurdity has to be dealt with. Yes this argument is flawed. But so is the whole shutting down the economy thing.
- xf1cf 5y agoWhy? Landlords were forced by edict to keep non-paying tenants while simultaneously footing the bill. This is completely unfair to landlords and makes the "speculative investment" argument into a government decree. The risk could not legally be mitigated. Otherwise, landlords would have evicted en masse everyone who couldn't pay after some period of time. I am friends with a few people who own houses. They were happy to help as long as their tenants could provide at least some payment. It's better in the long run to keep good tenants than to evict them even if it costs money in the short term. This isn't true in general however, and several places have toxic tenants who have refused to pay and are taking advantage of the moratorium. This is the literal definition of theft by decree. Making landlords whole should be top priority if their intention is to save the housing market. Imagine if they didn't - what would happen? Landlords would require stellar credit, several months payment up front, and regular financial checks. This all assuming they just don't pack up and sell their property (which has gone up significantly in value) thereby reducing the available places to rent.
- emodendroket 5y ago> Imagine if they didn't - what would happen? Landlords would require stellar credit, several months payment up front, and regular financial checks. This all assuming they just don't pack up and sell their property (which has gone up significantly in value) thereby reducing the available places to rent. So the nightmare scenario here is more people own their homes? I’m not sure I see why that’s bad, but it seems just as likely that they’re selling to other landlords more able to handle the vicissitudes of the market.
- xf1cf 5y agoWhere I live Californians have absolutely decimated the market. A few realtor buddies of mine say they almost exclusively deal in cash buyers from there and I was almost outbid on my own house several years ago by the same people. The net result is either these homes will go to the wealthy in a state with outsized influence (California), or they will be purchased and lived in by them. This pushes the locals even further out of the market and doesn't really do anything to resolve the current supply shortage we have. For Duplexes though I think you are correct. Likely they will sell to far more stringent mega-corps capable of withstanding 100 year events.
- WalterBright 5y agoIt's analogous to the government declaring it is ok to steal from a supermarket. The free market relies on the government protecting property rights. When there is a significant risk that the government is not going to protect property rights, and even legalize outright theft, the end result is commonplace in such countries: Businesses refuse to invest in those countries, and they have poor economies that people try to escape from and move to the US.
- emodendroket 5y agoLandlords are welcome to sell their property (at a likely tidy profit from what they bought it at, I might add, given current prices) and go elsewhere, if that’s what they would like to do.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe price they can get for it will be reduced by the new risk of rent moratoriums. There's a general exodus of landlords from Seattle going on due to a series of punitive laws passed against them by the Seattle City Council. https://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/editorials/stop-new-rental-regulations-to-preserve-housing-supply/ https://www.seattletimes.com/opinion/editorials/stop-new-ren... What this means for renters is less places available for rent, at much higher prices.
- emodendroket 5y agoMaybe it will but the current market shows the exact opposite trend.
- rhizome 5y agoIt's not a bad use of tax dollars to directly benefit tax payers.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoIt's a little more gray when the person making the decision is facing a recall election and the subset of taxpayers befitting are a demographic (property owners) that is proportionately very likely to vote.
- rhizome 5y agoIt's not gray. The recall is BS and the recompense would have happened anyway. Well, maybe not if fucking Caitlyn Jenner was governor.
- ryan93 5y agoif they werent taxed in the first place they would also benefit
- gregorymichael 5y agoWonder what percentage of landlords are big corporations vs. mom and pops who invested in a multi-unit instead of a 401k.
- pmoriarty 5y agoAccording an Atlantic article titled "BlackRock Is Not Ruining the U.S. Housing Market"[1]: "The U.S. has roughly 140 million housing units, a broad category that includes mansions, tiny townhouses, and apartments of all sizes. Of those 140 million units, about 80 million are stand-alone single-family homes. Of those 80 million, about 15 million are rental properties. Of those 15 million single-family rentals, institutional investors own about 300,000; most of the rest are owned by individual landlords. Of that 300,000, BlackRock -- largely through its investment in the real-estate rental company Invitation Homes -- owns about 80,000... "Megacorps such as BlackRock, then, are not removing a large share of the market from individual ownership. Rental-home companies own less than half of one percent of all housing, even in states such as Texas, where they were actively buying up foreclosed properties after the Great Recession. Their recent buying has been small compared with the overall market." [1] - https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/06/blackrock-ruining-us-housing-market/619224/?utm_source=feed https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2021/06/blackrock-...
- s1artibartfast 5y agoWhat portion of the individual landlords own multiple units and were operating in the green during the pandemic? Also, this is looking at only 80/140 million units which are singly family. I expect if you look at the other 60 million multi family units, the results would be the exact opposite. How many high rise apartment buildings in SF and NY are owned by individuals?
- JKCalhoun 5y agoAgree. And further, in which direction is the industry moving? It looks as though that my kids will be unable to buy a home and may be renters-for-life — as with an increasingly larger percentage of the upcoming generations. No doubt, like in every other pursuit of Capitalism, there will be mergers, buyouts, and consolidation of the entire "rental industry".
- freerobby 5y agoIf the State is protecting debtors from going through bankruptcy, it seems appropriate that the State compensate the creditors who would otherwise be able to make claims as part of bankruptcy.
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 5y agoHere's an analogy. The police seize your car, which you needed in order to get to work. You stop earning income from the job you used to be able to commute to, but you still owe rent. You're still making car payments too. A year later, they give it back to you. Is it right for them to do that without compensating you for the loss of your car/income? At the very minimum, they should have been making the car payments for that period. A closer analogy is that the government seized your apartment for a year while still keeping you on the hook for mortgage payments and is now giving it back.
- nielsbot 5y agoIt's complicated, though, right? Maybe landlords losing their rental properties would allow more people to become homeowners. Earning money by charging rent (at a profit) is pure capitalism.
- moftz 5y agoPeople not able to scrape together enough for a down payment on a house aren't magically going to be able to afford one if landlords need to sell their properties. A decrease in market value of rental properties due to major increase in sales is just going to invite private equity firms that will come in and snatch them up from the smaller landlords that cannot afford to continue. A better system to increase homeownership would be to reduce the need for down payments. Plenty of people can afford a mortgage and the other costs of homeownership but simply cannot save up the initial investment. The government already offers student loans for tens of thousands of dollars with no collateral or down payment, why not do the same for mortgages? Obviously its a little different than college degree, you can't sell your degree to pay off the loan but I could see a future where some sort of federal mortgage program can exist.
- nielsbot 5y agoThank you for a reasonable response to a very hypothetical question.
- lucian1900 5y ago
- sdf131 5y agoThe renters got to live somewhere for free for a year. It's not a bailout for the landlords, it's paying what's owed to the landlords. Of everyone involved, the renters are the only one who received something in exchange of nothing.
- curryst 5y agoI empathize with the desire, but I don't think there's a good way to do that. Rental properties are investment vehicles, and their pricing is influenced by that risk. You can harm the landlords short-term, but rents are likely going to rise to compensate for that increase in risk. On the other hand, it would make rental properties more risky without really impacting the risk to primary residences. It may decrease the price to outright buy properties if the market won't bear the increase in rent, making rental properties less profitable. Also, there have been a lot of offers to the unfortunate. Stimulus checks were substantial, as were increases in unemployment benefits. The removal of a year and a half of rent payments is also a significant benefit. Removing a liability is almost as good as income.