4 ms·
SimCity's main issue (and this was true as far back as SimCity 2000, maybe earlier) is that the "car traffic" goes from residential -> industrial -> commercial
by dragontamer 5y ago
SimCity's main issue (and this was true as far back as SimCity 2000, maybe earlier) is that the "car traffic" goes from residential -> industrial -> commercial in roughly that order.
This means that one plot of industry + one plot of commercial is enough to satisfy an entire residential neighborhood's worth of traffic planning.
Similarly, one plot of residential + one plot of commercial is enough to satisfy an entire industrial zone worth of traffic.
As this design decision became more and more widely known, power-gamers took advantage of it to make weirder and weirder cities that don't look like a real city at all.
------------
Cities: Skylines has a better traffic simulator. But its got too much emphasis on traffic simulation without actually having enough controls over traffic.
Police departments can only go as far as traffic lets them. Optimize for traffic, your police cover a greater area. Schools only go as far as traffic lets them, optimize for traffic, your schools cover a greater area. Etc. etc.
------------
I guess I'm liking OpenTTD, even though its not really a citybuilder. You can plan the routes of every train, bus, airplane, and boat. The cities do NOT grow naturally (the more traffic you provide, the more they grow. Its not like SimCity / Cities:Skylines where you need to provide a variety of services to make a house grow... its assumed the cities "figure out the details" as long as you provide enough traffic planning).
Its simplified and "less realistic" than Cities: Skylines. But because its a bigger focus on traffic-planning that Cities: Skylines, its a more "honest" game IMO.
If you're gonna make all elements of the game rely on traffic, then focus on traffic like OpenTTD does.
- johnday 5y agoCities:Skylines was built from the ground up to be a platform for modding and expansion. While the base game itself is solid, there is a staggering quantity of high-quality mods which expand the functionality and control you have over your cities. The most obvious one that springs to mind is Traffic Manager, which allows you to go in and change the direction of any individual turning lane to maximise throughput and efficient road usage.
- Aperocky 5y agoThe scale is a problem, the largest city are no more than 2 miles wide yet apparently people will struggle to drive their cars 300 ft because they somehow cannot walk at all. The traffic is ridiculous too, having 40 houses on a street? Traffic is going to be so insane! Oh and did I mention it took them 1 hour of commute to get to somewhere that is only half a mile away? This traffic simulator is crooked. Thank god for NAM.
- hutzlibu 5y ago"people will struggle to drive their cars 300 ft because they somehow cannot walk at all." Ah, this is sadly a bit too realistic, no?
- dragontamer 5y agoTropico is pretty good, but has the opposite problem. Your people are too poor to typically afford a car. So you set up a fancy car network (aka: parking garages), but the majority of your citizens spend hours walking everywhere, slowing your city to a crawl. You try to fix the problem by making "free busses", but setting up good bus routes remains difficult. You end up clicking the "free cars" button at great costs but... it does in fact solve that problem. ---------- There's also cheeky political commentary that Tropico is fully aware of. Catering to the religion faction increases your birthrate, but diminishes the academics. You'll get fewer high school graduates / college graduates, so industries like Oil refining become impossible. Or, you can cater to academics who tend to become Capitalists, but then they get angered by communist aligned policies like free cars and/or free housing. Then you suddenly go full communist, and the Americans invade, ending your reign. Or vice versa, if you go full capitalists, the USSR invades and the game ends. Then you start a new game and tell your hackers to steal the White House. (What? I never said this game was perfectly realistic...)
- pram 5y agoSkylines is absolutely a lot better, but the traffic system is weird and tedious. Especially managing stuff like trash and dead bodies. I'd end up following a single vehicle around to see what the bottleneck was, multiply that x100 for a huge city and it quickly sapped the fun.
- nwallin 5y agoCities:Skylines has a mod called Traffic Manager which lets you ... manage traffic. It gives tools that are sorely lacking in the base game, such as setting an intersection to have traffic lights, timed traffic lights, four way stop signs, two way stops+two way yield, control when/where vehicles are allowed to change lanes, where crosswalks are, whether vehicles are allowed to pull into an intersection if there's not enough space for them to leave the intersection, etc. By default, Cities:Skylines will despawn vehicles that have taken too long to get to where they're going and just warp them there. There's a hard cap on how bad traffic can get. Traffic Manager lets you disable that ... feature. Traffic Manager IMHO fixes the dishonesty you mentioned. C:S with TM is a more complete, more correct, more honest game than vanilla C:S is. There's a youtube channel where most of what he does is takes a city from a viewer with shitty traffic and fixes all the traffic problems.