3 ms·
So... imagine there's some fictional ETF that rises at exactly the rate of inflation. At the end of a year, your $100k investment is $102k. Still buys the same
by noduerme 5y ago
So... imagine there's some fictional ETF that rises at exactly the rate of inflation. At the end of a year, your $100k investment is $102k. Still buys the same number of Big Macs, potatoes, whatever.
You then have to pay tax on the $2k gain. You've lost purchasing power. Let's say your balance is now $101,800.
If you looked at this as monetary policy (rather than tax policy), wouldn't this essentially be a negative interest rate? Over time, wouldn't inflation rise exponentially?
Now, suppose the ETF tries to pace inflation + tax. Where does this extra money come from? Debt? Thus more inflation.
I find it interesting that the poster from Denmark considers it no big deal; Denmark has had negative interest rates for several years. That may make sense in a small, aging country that needs to stave off deflation, but the US currently has the opposite problem - inflation. Wouldn't a tax on inflationary "gains" send it into hyperdrive?