6 ms·
Supreme Court says over 200 patent judges were improperly appointed
- cyb_ 5y agohttps://archive.is/CYQeM https://archive.is/CYQeM
- BuyMyBitcoins 5y agoI know that most patent lawsuits end up being filed in some East Texas District Court. Is this ruling going to change this convention, or invalidate those rulings? Edit: More detail about the East Texas thing. Apple decided to close its retail stores in that region so they can hopefully avoid patent troll suits there. https://www.macrumors.com/2019/02/22/apple-closing-stores-in-eastern-district-texas/ https://www.macrumors.com/2019/02/22/apple-closing-stores-in...
- josaka 5y agoProbably unrelated, but the ruling in TC Heartland LLC v. Kraft Foods Group Brands LLC made it somewhat harder to sue in EDTX.
- nceqs3 5y agoOnly somewhat. Any company that has locations there or a tech company that has its services available and used there can still be sued in the eastern district. See the recent VLSI Technology v Intel ruling.
- rudyfink 5y agoGenerally speaking, this decision should not alter decisions in the district courts. Today's decision concerns filings in a specific agency court (the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent_Trial_and_Appeal_Board https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Patent_Trial_and_Appeal_Board) created in 2012 as part of the American Invents Act. Also, the Western District of Texas and Delaware have more filings these days than the Eastern District of Texas. The case-filing numbers for 2020/2021 collectively are WDTX (~30%), DDE (~26%), and EDTX (~14%). There are a few things behind that change, but the biggest is probably a Supreme Court decision in 2017 (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TC_Heartland_LLC_v._Kraft_Foods_Group_Brands_LLC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TC_Heartland_LLC_v._Kraft_Food...).
- seibelj 5y ago> Supporters of the procedure, called inter partes review, which is Latin for “between the parties,” say it helps combat patent “trolls,” or companies that obtain patents not to use them but to demand royalties and sue for damages. Opponents say the procedure is skewed toward the cancellation of valid patents. > The decision on Monday means the challenges will largely proceed as before, without changes to how the judges are appointed. The court’s narrow fix, subjecting the judges to additional supervision, fell well short of upending the current system. This does not help patent holders. The invalidation of patents will continue. There used to be a contingent on HN who profited off this system and would defend themselves in comments, but I haven't heard from them lately. Are any patent holders on HN still making a living doing the patent shakedowns? Genuinely curious.
- Animats 5y ago> Are any patent holders on HN still making a living doing the patent shakedowns? Genuinely curious. No. I've retired from inventing. Now that we've had a weak patent system for over a decade, trade secrets have become so powerful that nobody knows how anything new works inside. With patents, you have to disclose.
- seibelj 5y agoJust wrap your invention in an API - if it truly is novel, no one will be able to replicate it.
- nybble41 5y ago> if it truly is novel, no one will be able to replicate it. Novel and non-obvious. Many novel concepts are easily replicated from first principles given sufficient incentive. Only in rare cases is the solution non-obvious. Patents are most valuable to the inventor when reverse engineering or reinvention is more-or-less inevitable; to the public, whom the patent office is supposed to represent, they serve a purpose only in cases where the invention would otherwise be likely to remain a trade secret indefinitely. And that's only if the patent clearly describes the key elements of the invention such that it could actually be recreated, and doesn't last so long that the invention is thoroughly obsolete by the time the patent expires.
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoThe Opinion [1] is quite well and entertainingly written, if you have a few minutes. (The dissents, too.) [1] https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-1434_ancf.pdf https://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/20pdf/19-1434_ancf.pdf
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoOne of the things I would encourage people to do, even if they are not lawyers is to actually read the supreme court opinions for yourself. Anybody, no matter if you agree or disagree with their political leanings, who actually makes it to the US Supreme Court is crazy smart, and in general a good writer. In addition, they are assisted by really smart clerks. Because of this, their opinions tend to be quite readable and and many times quite entertaining (regardless of your political persuasion, the late Antonin Scalia wrote some memorable opinions). Democracy really does work best if the average person takes time to learn about their government and the issues. Reading through Supreme Court judgements, concurrences, and dissents, is actually quite accessible and is a very nice summary of the arguments for and against a position, as well as how the judges are intepreting the hundreds of years of jurisprudence and precedents.
- simonh 5y agoI agree completely, and I'm not even a US citizen. Nevertheless a lot of decisions made in the US have global reach and I find it useful to have a working knowledge of the US political and legal system. Some of it is bonkers, I have to say, but it has reasons (both good and bad) for being so and often these reasons bubble up to the top in SCOTUS decisions.
- jan_Inkepa 5y agoThe legibility of American supreme court rulings is really wonderful and a US national treasure - the democratic value of having judgements be scrutable to citizens probably shouldn't be underestimated. Scalia was in particular an amazing stylist. I remember deciding to check out supreme court proceedings for the UK and finding them absolutely impenetrable in comparison. I wonder if countries with very different legal systems (e.g. France, which doesn't have such an emphasis on common law / legal precedent to my understanding) have more readable/accessible-to-non-professionals judgements/proceedings still.
- henvic 5y agoIf you want to learn more about how patent system works and how the troll lawyers take advantage of society by using it to terrorize inventors, I recommend you watch the documentary by X-Plane's creator Austin Mayer, The Patent Scam. https://www.thepatentscam.com/ https://www.thepatentscam.com/
- Ballas 5y agoI watched it, but the way it is presented makes it really difficult to consume. That is unfortunate, because I think the message is really important.
- vmception 5y agoI would like to see more judicial review of Administrative Law Judges and similar creatures This one was just okay, glad they looked into it
- MikeUt 5y ago> The appeals court agreed, ruling that the judges performed important work without supervision and so were “principal officers” under the Constitution, meaning that they had to be appointed by the president and confirmed by the Senate. What bothers me is that granting a patent is easy, but invalidating one requires a "principal officer" and is treated as a huge infringement on property rights. What about the rights of everyone else, who are forbidden from using a technology by the patent-holder? Isn't that a much greater infringement upon liberty or property, than invalidating a patent?
- cratermoon 5y agoReplace "patent" with "parcel of land". Now how does it sound? What bothers me is that selling a parcel of land is easy, but invalidating the sale requires a "principal officer" and is treated as a huge infringement on property rights. What about the rights of everyone else, who are forbidden from using a parcel of land by the land owner? Isn't that a much greater infringement upon liberty or property, than invalidating the sale of a parcel of land?
- MikeUt 5y agoParcel of public land. An overworked bureaucrat probably shouldn't be selling those off cheaply, should they? Some private land is even subject to the right to roam*, so the public can still access it. *https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Freedom_to_roam
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Parcel of public land America bootstrapped its private property market. (No. Bad elephant.) All of her land was "first" public land (or royal land) and then granted to private persons.
- cratermoon 5y agoAll of it was home to people already here, who didn't claim ownership the way we think of private, or even public, property. Perhaps "stolen land" would be apt.
- mbfg 5y agoNow let's do the supreme court