5 ms·
Train Rides seem to be ideal for any trip less than 4 hours. You don't have as much security concerns, you have far more legroom, and the constant ability to w
by dragontamer 5y ago
Train Rides seem to be ideal for any trip less than 4 hours.
You don't have as much security concerns, you have far more legroom, and the constant ability to walk around the cabin at all times (often to the dining car where you can get overpriced beer / light meals, but... better than nothing at all). Hour-for-hour, a train ride is far more comfortable than a plane ride.
However, once we start looking at 4-hour or 8-hour train rides, the idea of a 2-hour or 3-hour plane ride just starts to make more sense, even with 30+ minutes of security + many minutes of "Taxi'ing on the runway" involved. Flying at 500mph just makes more sense than train rides at 50mph.
--------------
An exception is when the ride itself is part of the journey: if you want to see the entire countryside, the train is superior.
Planes fly over everything and are often high up in the clouds, so you don't get to see the whole ground.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoAgree. (And bring your own food.) I would love to see someone come up with a few US Rail Pass itineraries for those of us needing a hand to hold. It would seem to be a rather fun thing to blog. It's almost a puzzle of sorts to keep it to 10 trips, within 30 days, maximize the tourism potential (whatever that means) with Amtrak lines. Bonus points for things to see at each destination, food, cheap places to stay....
- dragontamer 5y agoI have to imagine that just running along the Northeast Regional is the big one. Its the most profitable line of Amtrak for a reason. Norfolk Virginia is just a short bus-ride to Virginia Beach and serves as either the starting point, or ending point of the journey. Travel north to Washington DC, then Philadelphia, then New York City, and then Boston. That takes you across a major cultural center of the USA that pretty much covers the founding of the country (Philadelphia being the original capital of the USA and the location of the Liberty Bell and original Continental Congress. Wash. DC as the current capitol, a beach trip just for giggles, and NYC for plays / New York talk shows / food / etc. etc.) The train is ridiculously optimized for New York City / Washington DC, with a dropoff point in Union Station Wash. DC and Penn Station in New York City. Both are connected underground to the greater subway systems, so you pretty much have access to the entirety of both cities from the train alone. (In contrast: an airplane ticket to either location will still need an Uber / Taxi to bring you into the city proper). Union Station in Wash. DC in particular is less than a 1-mile walk from the US Capitol building, a bit over 1-mile to the Smithsonian proper. While Penn Station is literally next to Madison Square Garden, so you're able to just get out and enjoy some basketball events. You're on Manhattan Island proper, and the subway will take you to any reasonable tourist attraction.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI would counter that the Starlight Express on the West coast as well as the California Zephyr between Emeryville, CA and, say, Denver, CO are probably two of the more stunning routes for the scenery?
- dragontamer 5y agoThat's a good point. Northeast regional is pretty much traversing over the megacity that is the WashDC -> New York City area. You're looking at people and culture, and probably need to plan your route very carefully (Ex: to ensure you actually have something to do in NYC, you might want to buy some Broadway tickets, or find a ticket to your favorite talk-show host). In contrast, California Zephyr / Starlight Express has a lot more rugged mountains, stunning coastlines, and nature to explore. This is a longer route but you traverse across much more "nature" so to speak. So it depends what you want to see.
- RosanaAnaDana 5y agoSouthwest Chief is the king of western Rail routes. Air conditioned car and the phenomenal almost alien beauty of the desert southwest. No reason to take it past ABQ however.
- Larrikin 5y agoAs someone who grew up in Richmond I'd argue the river, especially if you know where to go on the river, is just as nice as Virginia Beach with more stuff to do on land and culture in Richmond.
- weimerica 5y agoWhen I did my post-secondary Eurotrip I purchased the Euro pass and scheduled my train travels to be overnight such that I could wake up in a new city. Leave Sweden to wake up in Berlin, leave Berlin to wake up in Nürnberg, etc. Made for a great form of travel IMHO. Got to wake up and watch the sunrise over the countrysides was beautiful. Though I do love your point, I’d love to travel the “Wild West” regions via train.
- sokoloff 5y agoI did the same, but it was mostly to avoid having to buy hotel rooms. :)
- distances 5y agoSleeping compartments are AFAIK about the same price as hotel rooms. I used to sleep on the benches when a bit younger, but stopped that after a couple of sleepless attempts. Nowadays I do night trains solely for the time saving reasons.
- sokoloff 5y agoYeah, this was broke interning 20 year-old me, so 2nd class seating it was, because that was pre-paid with the pass.
- HWR_14 5y agoTrains are also great if you can sleep on the go. Board a train at night with no real wait. Settle in and sleep. Wake up halfway across the country. As long as you want to stop and explore (possibly small) cities along the way it's a great way to travel.
- jdhn 5y ago>You don't have as much security concerns For now. I feel that it's only a matter of time before the TSA gets involved, and that train ride that was hyped up as being quicker than a plane ride will suddenly no longer be as quick.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoTSA tried once. Amtrak, who has actual police with actual arrest powers, said next time they showed up and harassed Amtrak's passengers, they'd get thrown in jail. IIRC, Amtrak and TSA came to a face saving agreement that essentially made it clear that TSA has no say in Amtrak security. Unlike an airport that has many airlines, Amtrak stations only serve Amtrak so they have complete control. Not sure how things work at Canadian stations that Amtrak services but I'm betting it's not through a TSA type of situation.
- systemvoltage 5y agoGreetings HN, please start a startup that wipes TSA out of business.
- astrange 5y agoIt could get even faster if they'd stop boarding the train as if it was a plane at some stations. https://www.vox.com/2014/3/31/5563600/everything-you-need-to-know-about-boarding-an-amtrak-train https://www.vox.com/2014/3/31/5563600/everything-you-need-to... https://www.vox.com/2018/12/4/18123624/amtrak-boarding-rules-union-station-dc https://www.vox.com/2018/12/4/18123624/amtrak-boarding-rules...
- CPLNTN 5y agoLiving in Europe and traveling by train for 7/8 hours every two months for work. What kind of shitty train does only 50mph? I would say the convenience it’s highly dependent on the destination. Here the train station it’s often near the city center while to get to the airport you need additional transportation, As you said you have more legroom but also there is enough space to use a laptop and actually work connected to Wi-Fi. I’m not limited in what and how much I can carry with me, and the train is much quieter than a plane. And finally, the train is much less stressful and traveling time doesn’t really matter when is the company’s time. I would say that if you don’t have an airport in a 30km radius from the destination, the train still wins around until 8hours trips. Above, I would consider travelling with the airplane.
- walto2 5y ago> What kind of shitty train does only 50mph? In the US, Amtrak shares rails controlled by the freight operators. Amtrak trains can be delayed indefinitely, as the freight trains always get priority, even when they are off schedule. These delays are unpredictable in timing and length. I used to do the Seattle/Portland route regularly and 1 - 2 hours extra/unplanned travel time wasn't uncommon. Average speed was well less than 50mph.
- mynameisash 5y agoA few years back, we flew to SEA->MSP to visit family but opted for Amtrak for the return trip. It did happen to save us a couple hundred dollars and the circus that is TSA & airport security, but it was 36 hours. When we were moving, it was a reasonable speed (certainly nowhere close to a TGV). The problem was that we had multiple stops, such as maybe four hours sitting in Spokane. I would happily spend 12hrs on a train to do that trip -- even 18hrs overnight -- but 36 is way too much.
- musicale 5y agoThe local 1-hour stops and lengthy freight train delays really slow things down drastically for Amtrak. If the train was just moving all the time it would be a lot less painful. The trains are stinky and dumpy, usually with absurdly high fares, but if they kept moving they would be tolerable. The rail pass is nice because it allows for stopovers, but the Amtrak trips in between are going to be a drag. Perhaps some trains should remake themselves to be more like cruises, with luxury amenities (delicious food and drink, gym/exercise classes/spa/wave pool, on-train entertainment, live DJ/music and dance floor, interesting lectures and debates, celebrity meet & greet, arts and crafts, on-train library and book discussions, games and social activities, movie theater, etc.) so you wouldn't actually want to get off the train and you wouldn't care about the horrible delays. There could be stopovers at interesting places, and local tours. Or maybe there could be "work cars" with comfortable desks/chairs, high-speed internet access, coffee and snack service, etc..
- otabdeveloper4 5y agoTrains compete with cars, no with airplanes. People still make long-distance car trips despite the fact that airplans exist.
- culopatin 5y agoDriving is about the freedom of either having a car when you get there, or about making it a road trip taking detours on your way there. None are available with the train unless you can take your car with you. At that point, the competition is over between them unless the train is much cheaper, which is not the case in the US, not to mention a 4h car trip takes 8 with Amtrak. So the train has nothing going for it against a car at least in my area. If you don’t need a car then no one will choose to sit for 8hs for more money when you can get on a plane for 1.5h plus 30m of security and be there.
- otabdeveloper4 5y ago> Driving is about the freedom of either having a car when you get there, or about making it a road trip taking detours on your way there. Generally, no. The calculus changes significantly when children (more than 1), old people and/or luggage is involved. Most travel isn't just traveling with a suitcase and +1 for tourism purposes.