2 ms·
> I think Twitter and News Companies who repeat libelous and defamatory tweets about people should be liable. Actually, given how defamation works in the US, e
by jcranmer 5y ago
> I think Twitter and News Companies who repeat libelous and defamatory tweets about people should be liable.
Actually, given how defamation works in the US, even without Section 230, it's very hard to see how they'd be liable.
In the US, if the defamation is towards a public figure (which it is for every case you'll hear about), then it's not enough that the statement be demonstrably false, but it also has to be made with "actual malice." That means you need to demonstrate that the speaker either knew it was false or acted with reckless disregard as to its veracity.
Since Twitter basically publishes everything its users do, there's no way it can form sufficient mens rea to defame anybody merely by publishing a tweet.
Oh, and loosening up defamation law in the US would run afoul of this pesky thing called the First Amendment.