4 ms·
Isn't that what any investment is? Okay, maybe not debt issuance, but secondary market maybe?
by Ekaros 5y ago
Isn't that what any investment is? Okay, maybe not debt issuance, but secondary market maybe?
- ffggvv 5y agono buying amazon stock pre profit wasn’t a ponzi. because actual value was being created and there is even physical assets backing the value. and presumably some future cash flow to justify the current price. (which it has more than justified) crypto has none of this
- thebean11 5y ago> crypto has none of this It's pretty easy to think of a counterexample to this.. Cross border payments, collateralized loans, drugs, gambling, prediction markets, inflation/instability hedge. Whether or not you disagree that crypto is a good solution for any of these, it's pretty wild to claim "zero utility" in 2021.
- jeltz 5y agoI feel the EU did a much better job at solving cross border payments than crypto has. So I would say crypto is really only interesting for illegal stuff in places with working banks. As long as I do transactions within the EU they are easy and cheap. Which is s good thing the EU forced the banks to do.
- thebean11 5y agoI guess technically that's cross border, but not really what I meant.
- ImprobableTruth 5y agoIf there was a stock that advertised it self as never going to pay dividends/buybacks, I'd totally call it a ponzi scheme.
- CogitoCogito 5y ago> If there was a stock that advertised it self as never going to pay dividends/buybacks, I'd totally call it a ponzi scheme. I kind of understand what you mean, but I still feel like that situation would be different than cryptocurrencies. If you are buying stocks you have an ownership stake in the underlying asset. For example, you have the ability to affect change in the policy not to pay dividends/buybacks. So in a sense even in this case you still have something of value. But with cryptocurrencies you can't affect others in this way. You are all entirely independent actors and the value of your currency is really what someone will pay. It's just a medium of exchange no more no less.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- RivieraKid 5y agoNo, in a typical investment, you don't really care about what the market thinks, if your time horizon is long enough. Investments generate cash or utility to the owners. Dogecoin doesn't generate any value, it consumes it. It's fully dependent on market sentiment. It's a negative-sum game.
- CogitoCogito 5y ago> No, in a typical investment, you don't really care about what the market thinks, if your time horizon is long enough. Investments generate cash or utility to the owners. I don't think you can describe a "typical" investment in this way. Many investments lose value in the long run. Many investments value go to 0 in the long run. Your time horizon being long enough doesn't help here. In fact, it is actually what hurts you.