3 ms·
Because people generally spend a lower percentage of their income on cars and housing as their income increases. The minimums for shelter and transportation ar
by Retric 5y ago
Because people generally spend a lower percentage of their income on cars and housing as their income increases. The minimums for shelter and transportation are hard to avoid.
Put another way the percentage of people making say 50k with a 20+k worth of car(s) is greater than the percentage of people making 50 million a year with 20+ million in car(s). Similarly it’s not that rare for retirees to be house rich owning say a 1+ million dollar house while having less than a 50k a year income. On the other hand someone making 50 million is extremely unlikely to have 1+ billion dollars in personal property.
It’s true the rich may own a yacht, but they are also likely to completely avoid paying personal property taxes on it.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI see what you are saying. The question then becomes which taxes we want to be progressive or regressive, and what we want to tax in the first place. I don't think everything needs to be taxed, or all taxes should be progressive. In this light, I'm not sure what the rationale for a tax on yachts would be. It seems like it could be a way to generate government income, or discourage yacht ownership, but I'm not convinced these are sufficient reason.