4 ms·
How is property tax regressive? Renters don't pay it and it is a flat tax across home value?
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
How is property tax regressive? Renters don't pay it and it is a flat tax across home value?
- Retric 5y agoBecause people generally spend a lower percentage of their income on cars and housing as their income increases. The minimums for shelter and transportation are hard to avoid. Put another way the percentage of people making say 50k with a 20+k worth of car(s) is greater than the percentage of people making 50 million a year with 20+ million in car(s). Similarly it’s not that rare for retirees to be house rich owning say a 1+ million dollar house while having less than a 50k a year income. On the other hand someone making 50 million is extremely unlikely to have 1+ billion dollars in personal property. It’s true the rich may own a yacht, but they are also likely to completely avoid paying personal property taxes on it.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI see what you are saying. The question then becomes which taxes we want to be progressive or regressive, and what we want to tax in the first place. I don't think everything needs to be taxed, or all taxes should be progressive. In this light, I'm not sure what the rationale for a tax on yachts would be. It seems like it could be a way to generate government income, or discourage yacht ownership, but I'm not convinced these are sufficient reason.
- dexterdog 5y agoHow do renters not pay property tax? It's part of the cost of the property that the rent is based on.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoNot any more than I pay corporate taxes at the groceries because it is baked into the price of goods. In some places, property taxes could impact rent, but in many places it doesn't matter because the price of rent is much higher than the cost of owning the rental (including tax). This is most true in places where you can't build more housing inventory.
- Retric 5y agoIt’s not that home ownership isn’t more common as you move up the income scale. It’s that cars/homes become a smaller percentage of a persons income and overall wealth. At the extreme end, Bill Gates may own a 150 million dollar house, but that’s ~1/30th his annual income and 1/1,000th of his wealth. It’s not that nobody wealthy owns several properties, it’s that they generally have other things they want to spend their income on. Meanwhile owning a car worth even 3k is 1/10th the income of some at 30k, and many people have much more expensive cars at that income level. Worse the rate is generally higher on cars than homes. Similarly, nobody actually rich is “house rich” the way retired people are where their house is 10-30x their annual income. (500k to 1.5 million house with a 50k income.) So, even if you exclude rental income it’s still very regressive.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoHonest thanks, I got that from your other post. I would argue it is some sort modified regressive tax, where the bottom 35% of the people who don't own pay nothing, then your regressive tax percent of income kicks in.