3 ms·
People in brutal conditions become brutal. That part is fairly universal. And it is pretty easy to make them even more brutal by right training. All you have to
by watwut 5y ago
People in brutal conditions become brutal. That part is fairly universal. And it is pretty easy to make them even more brutal by right training. All you have to do is to reward aggression and to redirect their resentment toward weaker victim. Moreover, people who had pre-existing tendency to be brutal are overrepresented in units like that.
Second, antisemitism itself is not nazi invention. It was pre-existing in Eastern Europe, Ukraine and so on.
Third, "might is right" was strong aspect of nazi ideology where stronger have no responsibility toward weaker. So was "empathy is feminine weakness" and "manly men suppress these emotions and are brutal". Once you indoctrinated people into this, it does not matter whether they are Germans or Ukranians, they are more likely to be ok with committing atrocities.
> in exchange for warm clothes, gear and food, and the feeling of importance you must get when you can freely terrorize other people
It also needs to be acknowledged that lack of warm clothes means death and so does lack of food. We are not talking here about slight discomfort due to somewhat malnutrition. We are talking about no food full stop. Neither of those will make you nicer well empathetic person. Instead, they will make you focus on survival and loose whatever empathy you was previously capable of.
- the_af 5y agoI get what you're saying but the Trawniki were not collaborators doing what they could to survive. They were sadistic bastards, fully into what they were doing while at the same time "ideology-less" (beyond a basic anticommunist background). Put it this way: say an alien race enslaves humanity, you're first a starved POW, later given some privileges for good conduct, and later put in charge of some tasks on behalf of the aliens, which you must do in order to keep your privileges. In this thought experiment, do you see betraying your fellow humans? I want to think I wouldn't, but maybe I would. Telling on people, maybe even shooting some? Sure, it's possible. But you must remember the Trawnikis enacted much of the Holocaust. They raped and murdered women and children, and did so of their own free will. Do you see yourself raping a mother and murdering her children for the sake of keeping your privileges with the alien overlords? I don't. The Trawniki embraced this with willingness. They are the worst of the worst, unforgivable human scum. > People in brutal conditions become brutal. I reject this. People with the potential for brutality fully unleash this under brutal conditions. But there are decent people too, people you can break with brutality but which will never descend into it, they won't pillage, torture and rape no matter what you do to them -- and examples of this abound!
- seniorThrowaway 5y agoIf you haven't read Ordinary Men (https://www.amazon.com/Ordinary-Men-Reserve-Battalion-Solution/dp/0062303023 https://www.amazon.com/Ordinary-Men-Reserve-Battalion-Soluti...) by Christopher Browning I think you would like it, the book is about who follows appalling orders, why they do, and what does (and doesn't) happen to them if they don't. I think that most of us like to think we would be the moral exception, it offers some mental comfort, but it's far more likely that we won't.
- watwut 5y agoThe newer introduction from Richard J. Evans ia interesting tho. These were not entirely ordinary men as in representing ordinary Germans. They were righ-wing supporters and their political convictions made them ok with those orders. They perceived Reich as free long after everyone else was persecuted, after synagoges were burned etc.
- the_af 5y agoThis is an important distinction! Since not all of us are right-wing supporters, antisemites, or believe in the racial superiority and the innate right to rule of this or that race, this means it's not true that all of us would happily engage in rape and ethnic cleansing just because we're told by some authority figure that it's right to do so.
- the_af 5y agoI'm familiar with Ordinary Men and also with Hitler's Willing Executioners and I think they prove my point. > what does (and doesn't) happen to them if they don't This is key. What happens if they didn't follow orders? It turns out that... pretty much nothing. You could get away with not following orders. So those who did anyway, murdered, tortured and raped, are monsters in my eyes. Their lives weren't even in immediate danger! > I think that most of us like to think we would be the moral exception, it offers some mental comfort, but it's far more likely that we won't. If you think you would break down and commit rape, torture and murder, then I'm sorry for you. I'm nothing like you then, and most decent people aren't either. I'm not naive: I know there's a lot of behavior people will engage in under extreme conditions -- I can admit cannibalism, robbery, violence and lots of things unacceptable in normal society -- but there IS a line, and torture and rape are way beyond that line. I'm willing to admit under exceptional duress I'd betray my country and my friends. I can see myself being forced to shoot another human being "or else". What I cannot absolutely accept from you or anybody else is to claim "well, if I'm threatened with torture or death then I can break and be willing to rape women and crush their babies". I'm sorry but I cannot, and if you think you would, I hope I never meet you in person: you terrify me. If it comes to a point where someone tells me "unless you rape this child, I'll do the same to your children" then I might as well accept we're all doomed and it's beyond anything I can do. I won't commit rape, period. Note we're discussing the Trawniki men in this context. Read about what they did before claiming everyone in their position would do the same. These were really scum, the worst of the worst.