4 ms·
This is exhibit A in "The People vs The American Justice System". Take a plea bargain and get two years, go to trial and get eighteen. Where's the justice in th
by jdietrich 15y ago
This is exhibit A in "The People vs The American Justice System". Take a plea bargain and get two years, go to trial and get eighteen. Where's the justice in that? Either people are getting away with paltry amounts of jail time for pleading guilty, or they're being punished with long sentences for using their right to a trial. A ninefold difference in sentencing goes far beyond a proportionate incentive to avoid spurious trials. Even if this defendant was abusing the court, is sixteen years a fair punishment for wasting the court's time?
- tptacek 15y agoThe original plea deal offering of 2 years is what I find appalling; it smacks of a prosecutor who just wants to get the case off his desk as soon as possible. Read the whole sentencing memo; the 239 month recommendation seems entirely reasonable to me. He was offered 2 years, after being caught red handed orchestrating a many-months-long criminal campaign against his neighbors in retaliation for a molestation charge he confessed to. He took it to trial instead. In the process, he violated the terms of his release from confinement. He coached family witnesses in writing to lie about the circumstances of his offense. He told the court directly that the actual victims in the case were attempting to frame him. He was given by the court an opportunity to write an "Acceptance of Responsibility" statement as a means of mitigating his sentence; in it, he told the sentencing judge that he was the victim. As a result, the prosecution wrote: At every turn, the defendant has chosen not to accept responsibility for his actions and to obstruct justice. This Court has had a firsthand opportunity to see defendant’s dangerousness, lack of remorse, and disregard for the law. A lengthy sentence is needed to prevent the defendant from engaging in any further harm. Defendant is dangerous. Defendant is remorseless. Ardolf's own actions in front of the court suggest that he's a psychopath. What judge is going to go easy on someone like that? What gets me here is, if "wifi hacking" wasn't involved, this bind to the "Your Rights Online" neuroreceptors in HN reader brains and we wouldn't be arguing it. This is a crazy person who has thankfully been removed from public circulation. Forget about the wifi stuff. Total red herring.
- Natsu 15y agoI have to agree with you on this one. This isn't a case where someone had the book thrown at them because they did magical computer stuff. This is a case where someone got the book thrown at them because they were a dangerous asshole that went around ruining people's lives and was good enough at it that he would not have been caught most of the time. This clearly isn't his first offense, he has no remorse, does not accept responsibility, is a proven liar, and seems very likely to do all of this again. If I have any qualms, it's the fact that 239 months of prison is very expensive, but I'm not sure that there are any better solutions in a case like this. After all, I would expect him to target the judge and other court staff after something like this, for example, in addition to the people he was already trying to frame.
- deadmansshoes 15y agoAny reference to where he pleaded guilty to a charge of molestation (I presume this is the kissing incident)? He sounds like a psychopath, but if he was labelled a paedophile in the neighbourhood based on the statement of a 4 year old (or did the parents witness the incident?), then it's understandable there was retaliation.
- bzbarsky 15y agoThe article clearly says that the 4-year-old's mother saw the incident, for what it's worth.
- tptacek 15y agoThe sentencing memo says that after the mother saw the incident, he confessed to it. During the trial, he also confessed to it.
- deadmansshoes 15y agoWhere in the article? Not in the one this post links to. In a PDF linked from the article, it is stated that the mother had her back to Ardolf, and heard a "wet kiss." Ardolf then admitted to the father of the child he kissed him on the lips. My point is that accusing your new neighbour of being a paedophile on that basis could, if innocent of the charges, be a strong motivator for revenge.