3 ms·
In the case of a 17-year-old, are you really suggesting that this person - who has the full right to have actual sex with whoever they choose (bar perhaps a gua
by vacri 15y ago
In the case of a 17-year-old, are you really suggesting that this person - who has the full right to have actual sex with whoever they choose (bar perhaps a guardian) pretty much all over the developed world - that a photo of this person is just as much 'child porn' as a 10-year-old?
The world is shades of grey, not the black and white you're demanding.
- tptacek 15y agoArdolf named this electronic image “Matt’s Kids.jpg.” See Govt. Tr. Ex. 5-2. This is an image of known child pornography identified as the “Sabban series,” where the children depicted have been identified. It has been confirmed that at the time the photographs were created, the children were minors. See Govt. Tr. Ex. 81. The “Sabban series” of child pornography was created by two individuals in Brazil, who sexually abused and photographed three children over a several-year period.
- vacri 15y agoThat doesn't invalidate what's been said here. What you quote is not in the main article. And while most probably this series that you quote involved younger minors, it doesn't actually mention their age range - and 17 is still a 'minor'. inoop was presenting an opinion based on the information in the main article and you stomped on him and effectively claimed that everything he's ever said is now suspect. How many times has it happened that an article has used weasel words to paint an unflattering picture of someone, only for a more balanced view to come out later? inoop is asking people to look at the information that was presented rather than fire off a buzzword knee-jerk response. If you have more information, then present it before judging, don't judge people on their opinions that may change with your secretly held information.
- tptacek 15y agoI'm quoting the publicly available sentencing memo for this case.
- lotharbot 15y agoHe's quoting from http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2011/07/ardolffedssentencingmemo.pdf http://www.wired.com/images_blogs/threatlevel/2011/07/ardolf... Page 8 describes the photo in detail. It's not a 17 year old, "barely a minor". It's a prepubescent girl and two prepubescent boys.
- vacri 15y agoApparently HN doesn't allow me the right of reply here to either lotharbot nor tptacek. Weird. Anyway, the response is the same to both of you: I do not believe that either of you pore through every link in an article, reading all the way through before commenting. Particularly with court notes. No-one does. You're making a post-hoc defense. If not reading the court notes linked in that article before commenting is worthy of having your credibility and history derided, then my bet is that pretty much every single commenter in this whole thread is guilty of this. Also, lothar: your reference describes the picture of being of a prepubescent girl, which is different to the wired article which references a pubescent girl. From the context of inoop's comment, he's obviously going from the linked wired article and not the sub-linked court notes. edit: sorry, swapped the last two paragraphs, 'if not...' was not meant to follow on from 'also...'
- lotharbot 15y agoI can't speak for Thomas. For myself, I don't believe I've said anything that qualifies as deriding anyone's credibility or history (or trying to make a post-hoc defense for myself). I'm just trying to bring facts to light -- because a relevant issue was brought up, I took the time to pore through details I otherwise would not have. In short, the issue brought up was that the sentence seems excessive given that "child porn" could mean a picture of 17 year olds. Having done the research, it's clear that the picture was of much younger children, and that the length of the sentence was due to several factors beyond the "child porn" issue. So the ancestor post to this raised a valid question, but was ultimately wrong on the relevant facts.