8 ms·
No. (I hate such headlines) This is the 21st century. There's no one weird trick to being healthy, successful, having a high quality anything. Biological syst
by colechristensen 5y ago
No. (I hate such headlines)
This is the 21st century. There's no one weird trick to being healthy, successful, having a high quality anything.
Biological systems are complex and don't have a single variable which needs optimizing, they have many, need many, and every variable with leverage needs to be thought as a part of a whole.
- whatshisface 5y agoEvery part of your molecular biology is there for a reason. They're all necessary conditions for health. You take out the the mitochondria, the Golgi apparatus, the microtubules, some random protein that regulates membrane permeability, it doesn't work anymore. There isn't a part of your cellular biology which isn't important for a healthy brain. Your cells don't have infotainment systems, and if they did they'd be like the ones in a modern car that also unlock the doors and start the engine. (Edited to correct terminology)
- hollerith 5y agoOK, but "microbiology" doesn't mean what you think it means. (It is the study of microbes, i.e., very small independent life forms.) "Molecular biology" though would fit right in to your comment.
- torh 5y agoSpot on. Yet, people love "one trick" wonder -- just go on YouTube and search for "golf swing" or "lose fat", it's so easy you don't even have to leave the house.
- f6v 5y agoYeah you’ll rather blow your brains out than try to understand the totality of feedback loops in our bodies. The thing with biology is that you can always try to nudge one subsystem to fix something, but then there’s the next and the next, ad infinitum.
- drchickensalad 5y agoExcept it's not ad infinitum. It's ad constant, where constant is sufficiently frustrating for a few generations. Technology always gets there
- nyrulez 5y agoThis is indeed a big assumption. We have been able to create new systems from technology but are humans capable of reverse engineer complex biological systems or emulate them effectively is a complete unknown. For example, there are few groups trying to simulate a single cell for decades, and we are still extremely nascent in our ability to do so. It is possible that there are many facets of reality that are simply outside the comprehension of human brain. In fact, is is likely that most reality is outside our comprehension.
- cameronh90 5y ago"We have been able to create new land-based vehicles from technology but whether humans capable of heavier than air flight like birds is a complete unknown. It's possible that there are many facets of flight that are simply outside of the comprehension of human brain." You could make this exact same argument for all technology until it's discovered.
- tsimionescu 5y agoYes, and you'd be right to do so. Most technology that we can imagine will not exist within our lifetimes. People have been dreaming of flying apparatuses since the dawn of mankind, and we only built one in 1900, probably more than six thousand years since we first imagined the idea.
- Smithalicious 5y agoJust because it's always worked in the past doesn't mean it will always work in the future. I've actually spent some time thinking about this in the past - a big hidden assumption of science is that everything is knowable, which we know is not strictly true, and I'm not entirely confident that it's even approximately true.
- agumonkey 5y agoThing is, mitochondrial, AFAICR, has never been the main focus before. So it's still a bit useful to be able to review it for the mainstream. That said, +1 for holistic approach.
- EGreg 5y agoSo, Betteridge strikes again?
- grawprog 5y agoNot just within the body. Life itself is layers upon layers of interconnected systems from a micro to a macro to a global level. Humans have a very surface level understanding of the our internal systems that make our bodies work, we know next to nothing about most of the ecological and environmental systems we also rely on. Everything from our external environments, to the things that enter our bodies to all the things that live in and on our bodies, all the things play a part in our health and functioning.
- nyrulez 5y agoI think both can be true. While what you say feels holistic and true philosophically, in day to day, we cannot control for 1000 different variables and some things have more of an outsized effect than others. For example if someone wrote "Is Exercise the key to a healthy brain", it sure can look click-baity, but in practice it's a tried and tested lever to improve brain health. Sure, you can say "oh there are 10,000 other things that influence brain health and it's a very complex inter-connected system", but you miss the fact that not all of those 10,000 things are equally deserving of your time or even under your influence. In fact, things like exercise or meditation can fall under the "weird trick" category. If focusing on mitochondria's health falls under that "outsized effect" category is the thesis of the article and remains to be seen if it can be included in the same category as other tried and true influential levers.
- lamename 5y agoYou beat me to this thought, but the difference is that exercise and high-level lifestyle changes will include underlying changes in a million biological factors, including mitochondria. We see this over and over in press releases when new research is focused on one mechanism (e.g. mitochondria). To me "weird tricks" that capture whole body or lifestyle changes are at least worth paying attention to. While "weird tricks" in the name of a single biological mechanism are indeed overblown (but still worth knowing if you're in to that sort of information).
- nyrulez 5y agoI'd say what lies at top of the food chain of cause and effect is simply coming from "availability bias" i.e. we give more weight to what we know to be true. Yes some things have more downstream effects than others and that's where you get your bang for the buck. Whether mitochondria is just one mechanism or more of an over-arching one is what research is all about. For example, HRV feels like on obscure metric out of 100s of metrics. But it has been shown to now have hundreds of mental and physical benefits including longevity, that we don't necessarily understand why but it still has risen to the top. Same for intermittent fasting and so on. These are indeed "weird tricks" in a pretty literal sense but they do the job in predictable and often dramatic ways.
- phreack 5y agoSuch a headline almost reads like a joke. "Is blood the key to a healthy brain?" would also read as funny. Are neurons? Lungs? DNA? I understand the article is insightful but the tragedy of click bait headlines strikes again.
- LoveMortuus 5y agoThe following is sarcasm: My shaman drilled a hole in my head and now all of my headaches are gone, just like magic!
- u8mybrownies 5y agoYes but this isn’t just facts about a brain, it’s an article about facts of the brain and it wouldn’t be #1 on HN without a short, intuitive, attractive title. If the title listed 1,000 weighted parameters in the question it would be utterly unusable.
- refactor_master 5y agoSlightly off-topic: I remember a couple of years ago how “hydrogen sulphide may have role in cellular aging” morphed into “why sniffing farts is good for you”. It’s really all or nothing with these headlines.
- wyager 5y agoIt’s possible there are kolmogorov-simple optimizations that are evolutionarily complex, like the supplementation of a non-synthesizable metabolite. We’ve made plenty of discoveries like this in the past, such as with various mineral deficiencies. It seems like we’ve exhausted most of those, but there might be similar optimizations, such as not poisoning ourselves with microplastics or whatever.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- TX0098812 5y ago"Hacker news commenters hate him!"
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dang 5y agoOk, but please don't respond to just the headline. That just perpetuates the shallowness.
- colechristensen 5y agoI could have added more context. In this case, I think the headline is not just bait, it serves as the thesis of the whole article and unless the reader is uncommonly critical of such things, the whole thing serves as an argument for answering "yes" to the posed question. In most cases I do agree that discussing mostly the title results in little value.
- lcnmrn 5y agoCrazy idea: what if we can use mRNA or any other tech to make old blood young again by changing the chemical composition? The rest of the body follows along, it's proven.