3 ms·
The simple counter argument is that most life in nature does not end well or painlessly at all. Dying sucks. Especially when you are being mauled to death by so
by jillesvangurp 5y ago
The simple counter argument is that most life in nature does not end well or painlessly at all. Dying sucks. Especially when you are being mauled to death by some predator. The best you can hope for is that it will be quick. Violent death is a near certainty; unless some crippling decease gets you first. The reality of nature is that there are no nursing homes, only jaws of death.
It's of course not an excuse to be needlessly cruel. But it is a valid reason to re-consider how nature works. Leaving animals alone does not mean they get to die in their sleep surrounded by their loving families and mourned by their loved ones like we all hope for. Worse, a lot of the animals we kill in order to eat them exist solely because we eat them. Ceasing to eat them adds up to genocide.
We have entire sub species of all sorts of animals that would not exist or continue to exist if it weren't for the fact that we breed them in order to eat them. Cows, pigs, and chickens are good examples of animals that have no place in nature and would likely die out quickly because of the very same properties that caused us to breed them in that direction.
Many billions of animals would not exist if it weren't for the fact that we plan to eat them. Equating veganism to genocide is clearly a bit of a stretch. But just ask yourself if it is better for the animal and its species to not have existed at all or is eating meat under some circumstances perhaps not that unethical? It's what the rest of nature does after all.