3 ms·
Two comments here converge on a complete response to Chris DiBona's assertion: "A platform controlled by a single vendor and locked down by hardware vendors !=
by Zigurd 15y ago
Two comments here converge on a complete response to Chris DiBona's assertion:
"A platform controlled by a single vendor and locked down by hardware vendors != the Linux desktop "dream come true"
"For smartphones, sure. For desktops this is not going to happen for a long time if ever."
As much as Android is now both the dominant client Java and the dominant Linux userland, there are two things that have to happen before it is the Linux "dream come true."
First, it should become really open, without a Google controlled two-tier structure for OEMs. Not all open source, but open to all comers: Anyone who makes an Android device that passes compatibly tests should be able to ship the Android Market on it. In this, Microsoft is more even-handed with OEMs. Any OEM can license Windows, and they get the same thing HP and Dell get.
Second, Google needs to make this openness and evenhandedness happen for tablet makers, which are more like desktop PC makers than handset makers. Tablets are not tied to mobile networks, nor to mobile network operators' retail channels. There is no mobile operator dictating what the software content of a tablet must be in order for it to be accepted by their channel, so there is no excuse for the process to be less than transparent and open to every product that passes compatibility tests.
- kkowalczyk 15y agoIf you sign a deal with Google, you also get the same treatment as other companies that signed a deal with Google. The difference between Microsoft and Google is that if you don't license Windows, Microsoft gives you nothing. Big, fat 0. If you don't sign a deal with Google, you get 95% of Android. Your demands perfectly illustrate human nature: no matter how good you have, not matter how much you have, there's always more to want and demand. With Android Google is being generous to extreme, unprecedented levels. They give away, for free, with source code, technology that would require millions to redevelop from scratch, but that's not good enough for you. And the same time, you make no demands on Apple or Microsoft to be even 1% as generous as Google is. The restrictions that Google has on Android have very good rationale: to prevent explosion of incompatibilities, something that has plagued uncoordinated desktop Linux efforts for years and has no signs of being resolved. rpm vs. apt vs. yam. Gnome vs. Qt. etc. And finally, no matter how many of your demands Google will meet, people will always come up with more. You have already demonstrated that you'll find a fault with a very big and generous gift of Android. I can easily imagine that after Google lifts the restrictions that bother you so much (even though the likelihood that you're personally affected by them is 0) someone will consider that 30% royalty in Android Market is too high.
- throwaway32 15y ago>If you sign a deal with Google, you also get the same treatment as other companies that signed a deal with Google. Do you have any evidence to support this statement? Agreements of that nature are not normally made public, and the circumstances surrounding the google maps/GPS on android thing, means this is very likely not the case. >The restrictions that Google has on Android have very good rationale. Im so happy that google is choosing to restrict my freedom to use my devices for my own good, thank you google. >You have already demonstrated that you'll find a fault with a very big and generous gift of Android. I can easily imagine that after Google lifts the restrictions that bother you so much (even though the likelihood that you're personally affected by them is 0) Android is not a gift, its intent was never to charitably donate something to the community at large, its intent was to make google money. Their entire platform is based off of the open-source work of others, it did not spring forth from google fully formed, expecting reciprocation is not too much to ask.
- andylei 15y ago> Im so happy that google is choosing to restrict my freedom to use my devices Google is not 'restricting your freedom'. You can fork android and do whatever you want. > Android is not a gift, its intent was never to charitably donate something to the community at large, its intent was to make google money Intent is irrelevant. Pre Google: 0 commercially viable Linux based phones. Post Google: dozens. > Their entire platform is based off of the open-source work of others, it did not spring forth from google fully formed, expecting reciprocation is not too much to ask. They do reciprocate. The source for android is yours to hack.
- throwaway32 15y ago>Google is not 'restricting your freedom'. You can fork android and do whatever you want. that is a bit of a hobson's choice, sure (some of) the code is available (pre 3.0), but without a device that is open and able to run it, it may as well be closed. >Intent is irrelevant. Intent is everything, would you be right to suspect the motivations of a mining company conducting a review of environmental impacts, even if the results appear sound on the surface? >They do reciprocate. The source for android is yours to hack. Except for of course, gingerbread.