32 ms·
I’m very irritated about Scott’s foray into funding ethnic activist organizations. Her basic strategy is to give to organizations with expertise in an area, and
by rayiner 5y ago
I’m very irritated about Scott’s foray into funding ethnic activist organizations. Her basic strategy is to give to organizations with expertise in an area, and she projects that onto giving money to identity-based organizations, on the theory that those organizations are “experts” in the ethnic groups they purport to speak for.
> Because community-centered service is such a powerful catalyst and multiplier, we spent the first quarter of 2021 identifying and evaluating equity-oriented non-profit teams working in areas that have been neglected. The result was $2,739,000,000 in gifts to 286 high-impact organizations in categories and communities that have been historically underfunded and overlooked.
But if you look at the list of say Asian organizations funded by Scott, many are Asian progressive activists. I’m a card carrying Asian and I’ve never heard of any of them. As Matt Yglesias has pointed out, progressive activists are unrepresentative of the minority groups they purport to speak for: https://www.slowboring.com/p/yang-gang https://www.slowboring.com/p/yang-gang
For example, one organization Scott funded tries to teach Asian kids to dismantle the “model minority myth.” As far as I can tell, what they define as a “myth” is just how my Asian parents socialized their children to be.
The problem is that selecting particular Asian identity groups for funding is itself an exercise in using wealth and privilege to pick winners and losers. In this case, Scott is showering Amazon bucks on one side of a debate within the Asian community itself, distorting that debate.
- debrice 5y agoI believe it’s also an indirect way of voting with your dollars. While they probably don’t owe that much $$$ to the IRS, I suspect this will likely cover some of it while letting them decide where their tax should go (I don’t really have an opinion on this strategy/system, just thought it could add to the discussion)