8 ms·
The author doesn’t understand why people buy GME. It’s not to push the price up in a coordinated way or something else like that. It’s because it is understood
by dgellow 5y ago
The author doesn’t understand why people buy GME. It’s not to push the price up in a coordinated way or something else like that. It’s because it is understood that Citadel never covered it’s short position from January, after doing massive naked shorting to drive the price of GME down to zero. There is a belief that they are kicking the can further down the alley by creating more and more synthetic shorts, hidden in deep ITM long or other mechanisms, because they cannot actually cover their current position. And that eventually something will force them to cover, resulting in a massive short squeeze.
It’s not nihilistic at all, people who participate in this because they actually believe their analysis is correct and a short squeeze is imminent. That’s why in this framework buying at a cost below the floor (currently discussed at $20mio per share, seriously) is considered cheap.
The research people discuss on this topic on r/superstonk is interesting to read just to get an idea of what they are doing. Not that I’m saying a short squeeze will happen or not, I personally have no idea, but it’s a fascinating niche to become familiar with.
- mmiliauskas 5y agoNot sure why this being downvoted. Don't really have skin in the game when it comes to GME, but the naked shorting and creating short squeeze thesis has some legs, beyond the "stonks only go up" narrative. Burry was one of the first people to go long before all the craze.
- jw1224 5y agoI’ve tried to explain this on HN twice before and been immediately downvoted, despite my best attempt at explaining the nuances. Your comment sums things up well, thanks for sharing. For anyone else who’s curious to learn more, as mentioned, Superstonk[1] is the place to go. Don’t be put off by the name — Superstonk is dedicated exclusively to monitoring the GME situation specifically. It’s actually the third subreddit used for this since January — r/WallStreetBets has clearly been taken over by pump-and-dump schemes on a mass scale, and the older r/GME subreddit saw a mass exodus of users to the newly-formed Superstonk, after mods lost control of it to speculated “shill” posters. Plenty of evidence has arisen showing anonymous recruiters offering to pay Redditors to spread GME misinformation. I’d suggest filtering Superstonk posts to just the “DD” flair to hide the humour/camaraderie, which can understandably be a bit off-putting to outsiders, unfamiliar with the myriad of crazy events that have happened so far[2]. Having followed the GME saga very closely since January, one of the most enlightening revelations for me has been the blatant media manipulation surrounding GME. There’s just far too many examples to ignore — so perhaps it’s unsurprising that many people still think it’s simply a “Reddit meme stock” that’s run it’s course. If the DD is to be believed, this thing is far from over. Regardless, I’m thoroughly enjoying watching how it unfurls. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/ [2] https://gmetimeline.com/ https://gmetimeline.com/
- qeternity 5y agoIt gets downvoted because it’s nonsense. People who talk about naked shorting do not understand what it means. And in general people talking about these sorts of conspiracies definitely don’t understand options/greeks. Source: career hedge fund trader
- toomuchtodo 5y agoYou say this, and then it’s reported that funds are bleeding out $800M-$1B per day when GME and AMC rally, so ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-01/amc-gamestop-rallies-deal-shorts-another-591-million-blow https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-01/amc-games...
- jw1224 5y agoLast week’s 8-K filing revealed GameStop are actively assisting the SEC with an investigation into ongoing manipulation of their share price. They even disclosed to investors the risk of a further short squeeze on their stock. If they don’t have reason to believe that’s a possibility, it would never have been put on the record in a public filing.
- WJW 5y agoThey can believe it is an exceedingly remote possibility but nonetheless put it in the filing just in case. These filings contain many risk statements about events that do not eventually come to pass. In addition, assisting the SEC about 'ongoing manipulation' can just as easily mean that the SEC may be considering mass hyping of the stock through reddit to be manipulation. It does not mean that there is definitely shady stuff going on that GameStop is worried about.
- jw1224 5y agoBoth fair points, thanks for your comment. GameStop’s filing did note the following [1]: “the inquiry is not expected to adversely impact us” I feel this is a statement they would be unlikely to make if they felt the SEC’s investigation was likely to result in retail sell-offs. They’ve been able to use the recent dramatic increase in their share price to pay off $216m in debt a year early, and add a further $551m to their bank account. Plus, they’re currently in the process of raising an additional $1.1bn from additional share sales. The SEC themselves have commented on the investigation too [2]: "SEC staff continues to monitor the market in light of the ongoing volatility in certain stocks to determine if there have been any disruptions of the market, manipulative trading, or other misconduct," a spokesperson for SEC said in a statement. "In addition, we will act to protect retail investors if violations of federal securities laws are found." That last sentence leaves me feeling optimistic. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-09/gamestop-says-sec-is-investigating-trading-of-its-shares https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-06-09/gamestop-... [2] https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-sec-says-observing-market-meme-stocks-rally-2021-06-07/ https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-sec-says-observing-marke...
- christopherwxyz 5y agoThe most likely alternative, and the one that is least considered, is that short funds do not cover their position at all. Everyone loses.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dgellow 5y agoYep. That would make it clear that the system is fucked.
- christopherwxyz 5y agoLehman Brothers and Bear Stearns disintegrating did not bring total collapse to the financial markets. Citadel would be just one institution in a small collection of others. Ordinary investors lose, one or more funds lose. Nothing changes.
- sumedh 5y ago> Lehman Brothers and Bear Stearns disintegrating did not bring total collapse to the financial markets. The market started to collapse when the Fed stepped in to bailout banks and AIG and others.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> The research people discuss on this topic on r/superstonk is interesting to read just to get an idea of what they are doing. It can be interesting to read to see what they're thinking, but the material posted on /r/superstonk is basically QAnon for stonks. I took a quick look and their supposed floor price for GME has now crossed $30,000,000. They're all ecstatic that they're going to be kings in the future because they hold a couple shares of Gamestop.
- dgellow 5y agoIt’s definitely not qanon. You have to pass the first impression given by the heavy use of memes and the Reddit culture and check what they call “DD” (for Due Diligence, which is their way to say “research material”). Just filter posts by flair for this. Or check anything by u/criand or u/attobit. There is a lot of noise, but some interesting discovery have been done. It’s evolving over time as people find new elements to investigate or new events happen (such as the raise in reverse repo operations).
- gruez 5y agoIt might not be exactly qannon but it ticks a lot of the boxes. eg. "trust the plan", some sort of predicted event that never comes to pass but keeps on being pushed back, not to mention accusations of shills left and right.
- jw1224 5y agoI recognise those points you raised, and I can see how they sometimes look a bit culty. QAnon is not an appropriate comparison. Generally speaking, Superstonk is very welcoming of counter-DD. It’s members have good intentions (like /r/ApePhilanthropy for example), and there are lots of smart people doing legitimate research into an intentionally obfuscated industry, with a history of secrecy and corruption. But I do see what you’re getting at. Even without another squeeze the company has some genuinely exciting fundamentals, and it’s future prospects have never looked better. So many people think it’s just a great long-term investment, no matter what transpires along the way. Part of the “cult” problem is exacerbated by the inherent nature of the MOASS thesis. At its core, it’s Game Theory in action. The MOASS only works if a critical mass of retail investors allow it to. Individual voices spreading “FUD” only serve to sabotage the opportunity for everyone else. But at the same time, it’s in all the players’ best interests to base their strategy on reliable information. There have certainlu been a few occasions when users have gotten overexcited, promised things they shouldn’t have, or made claims they can’t back up. But honestly, overall I’m absolutely amazed by the community at self-policing it’s members, and striving for accuracy. A big part of this, I think, was the fact that Superstonk is now the 3rd home for GME. Investors have watched WallStreetBets turn in to a pathetic shell of its former self, overrun by bots and pump-and-dump schemes. Most users who were still interested by February had migrated to /r/GME, where good DD was being posted again. Unfortunately the mods there lost control of the sub, and it quickly became overrun with blatant “FUD” posts — usually from users with brand new accounts, and 0 post karma. The patterns were extremely obvious, and for many people, helped to reinforce their beliefs about market manipulation. Each time the core community migrated, the quality improved significantly. Superstonk has nearly 500K members — which is a lot, but, nowhere near WSB at its peak (10M members or so). Superstonk is a generally positive community, filled with people who’ve “held from $400 down to $40, and back again”. That kind of attitude is all that’s necessary by this point. Most members, I’m sure, would agree: the research has been done, and it’s just a matter of time. — For me, personally: I’ve found it to be a fascinating, eye-opening opportunity. No matter how things pan out, it’s been a uniquely enjoyable learning experience, and something I’ve very much enjoyed following.
- dehrmann 5y ago> It’s because it is understood that Citadel never covered it’s short I think you mean Citron. I assume Citadel is rolling in retail trader money, right now.
- gifnamething 5y agoThey don't mean Citron.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> after doing massive naked shorting to drive the price of GME down to zero The only evidence I’ve seen for this is a misreading of free float statistics and a misunderstanding of the difference between market makers and hedge funds. That said, your broader point is valid. Someone investing on this thesis is not a financial nihilist.