3 ms·
Our experience in the Web PKI is pretty stark. Assuming well-meaning, basically competent people, all you can hope for is that they can enforce some simple easy
by tialaramex 5y ago
Our experience in the Web PKI is pretty stark. Assuming well-meaning, basically competent people, all you can hope for is that they can enforce some simple easy-to-follow rules and you will need to check their work to keep them on the straight and narrow. To the extent they screw up and you miss it, the screw-ups will continue, to the extent the rules are too hard for them to follow they just won't.
But I don't see how that regime is useful here because the rules they would need to follow are anything but simple and easy-to-follow. To be effective they need to be more or less reverse engineering complicated drivers day in and day out. So I am not surprised the result is ineffective.
Actually I'd say the practical alternative, which you should indeed prefer in real life, is Class Drivers. Notice how that webcam you bought just plugs in and works? Same for your wireless mouse, the no-name USB headset and the 2TB USB hard disk you bought. Because those are standard classes of device, they don't need custom drivers.
This current practice is security theatre. There's the big show with the "certification process" and then actually they'll just ship whatever malware somebody pays for.
- jnxx 5y agoThen why not use an open source OS with generic drivers which are available in source code and can be inspected, and even build in an exactly reproducible way with a system like GNU Guix?
- franga2000 5y ago> the practical alternative, which you should indeed prefer in real life, is Class Drivers Class drivers are great, but they require devices to comply with standards, which are usually not very accommodating of whatever new bells and whistles manufacturers want to add. Putting RGB lighting on literally everything, for example, was not really considered when the standards were written.
- account42 5y agoRGB doesn't really need kernel-level drivers.