5 ms·
We had (have?) the same problem in my University. Our problem is that we have like 40.000 new students each year, so a simple "This is your new virtual campus.
by gus_massa 5y ago
We had (have?) the same problem in my University. Our problem is that we have like 40.000 new students each year, so a simple "This is your new virtual campus. Please confirm your account and update your password." will raise a lot of red flags.
The main problem is that the emails don't bounce, nor go to the spam folder. They just disappear in the air.
If the other person had send an email to you, then the messages usually are delivered. So in our case it's not so bad for old connections.
- pruepp 5y agoThanks, I appreciate your story, because it made me realize, that in our case the e-mails do actually bounce, at least partially. 40k a year is massive in my eyes. I feel like there needs to be a global allow list for educational/scientific/infrastructural orgs, that would always make spamming cases involving them sorted out for manual processing, instead of piping them into the basic if-spam-then-block algo. At the end of the day getting locked out like that is just bad service for everyone involved.
- gus_massa 5y agoIt's distributed in 10-15 buildings, so you don't realize the size until you must to print the midterm for all[1] of them. [1] Actually a big subset of them that has a math course in the fist year.
- pruepp 5y agoThat is impressive, I have to wonder how much autonomy the suborgs (faculties?) have, because how many students do you have in total, then? 160k-ish?! Getting blacklisted on that scale sounds akin to one side of a road between a town (i.e. campus) and a megapolis getting blown-up.
- gus_massa 5y agoWikipedia says "enrolls more than 328,000 students" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Buenos_Aires https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/University_of_Buenos_Aires . It's split in 13+1 faculties, and many other smaller entities (that sometimes are not so small). Each part is quite independent. I work in the +1 part, that is a "common" first year for all the students, but it actually has like 10 "flavors" [1] (The first year of Medicine is equal to the first year Odontology, but it's different of the first year of Law School.) The emails block is probably not so coarse, and is probably split in a cases for each faculty. (I don't have hard data, just guessing, and comparing the information from the 2-3 cases I know.) And it may be even cases where it's applied to smaller groups, because many of the departments in each universities run their own web and email servers. [1] The "flavors" don't have an official name, I just made up a name here.
- pruepp 5y agoOh wow, thanks for sharing that, I didn't realize how big unis can get, it's mind-blowing! Having (some) separate infrastructure for the faculties would make sense then. Less single points of failure :)
- bradknowles 5y agoThe University of Texas at Austin only served (serves?) about 50k students and about 20k faculty and staff. I used to help run their mail system. Our key tool that made the world of difference to us was the Ironport anti-spam appliances that we had sitting in front of the real mail servers. We sometimes got onto black lists, but we had good personal reputations with the big mail service providers, and were able to get quickly de-listed. It helped that I was the former Sr. Internet Mail Administrator at AOL, and I was friends with the principal SRE at the time for Gmail, etc…. But without those Ironport appliances running a highly customized configuration, we would have been dead in the water. Fortunately, we also had a really good working relationship with Ironport. So, we were able to do that job quite well across the entire University with about 1.5 guys — Don Nash was the primary mail administrator for UT Austin, and I stepped in to assist as necessary. But these days, I don’t think that would be enough. I think there are too many cowboys out there who just don’t care how much damage they do, or they actively enjoy doing as much damage as they possibly can.
- pruepp 5y ago"Only" 70k in total, damn! :D Thank you, I didn't know there were things like anti-spam appliances, so this makes me realize that the people running those systems definitely know what they're doing, so there must a reason for not considering things like domain age.