3 ms·
With the offensive posture of the NSA, I would be highly surprised if this weren't true. They can be compelled to do anything, and compelled to keep it secret.
by mikewarot 5y ago
With the offensive posture of the NSA, I would be highly surprised if this weren't true. They can be compelled to do anything, and compelled to keep it secret.
- sneak 5y agoIncompetence is more likely than malice. I am sure they have done both.
- rincebrain 5y agoWhile it's true that the NSA could feasibly compel them to do this, I would be reasonably surprised if they exerted that capability so casually that this many ended up uploaded in e.g. VirusTotal. If everyone thinks random signed drivers can be malicious, then they're more cautious about them, looking for them. If everyone thinks signed drivers are a sign of trustworthiness, it's much more likely that your malicious driver can wind up where it needs to be, and stay there without being noticed. My personal bet is heavily on malware getting signed either through a stolen cert/compromised signer or simple incompetence.
- xbar 5y agoI do not suspect this is a complete analysis of the risk.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chiph 5y agoWhile they could, I don't think so in this case, as the drivers mentioned report back to C&C servers in China. While the NSA could obviously set up servers there, the simpler case would be that they have not. Don't forget that the other mission of the NSA is to protect American computer infrastructure. Doing something like this where the driver distribution is so wide and indiscriminate would also argue against their involvement. My guesses are in order: 1. The driver authors copied source from somewhere else without understanding what it did. 2. Malicious intent from the Chinese firms. 3. Malicious intent from the CCP. 4. Any other reason.