4 ms·
That's not really contradictory. Lots of covid treatments have been discovered in hospital settings by doctors trying desperately to find something to help thei
by nicoburns 5y ago
That's not really contradictory. Lots of covid treatments have been discovered in hospital settings by doctors trying desperately to find something to help their patients.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoAnd those were later validated by evidence from clinical trials. Until clinical trials involving significant numbers of patients are available, there is not evidence according to the standards of medical science. That's the contradiction.
- effie 5y ago> there is not evidence according to the standards of medical science. What the hell are you trying to say? That doctors treating patients observations can be dismissed because they don't talk the academic language or their results don't follow academic guidelines? There is more to medicine than just clinical trials. Many different things can count as evidence, even if they are not up to your academic standard. Doctors observations, population-level improvements, and studies of different cohorts. There are levels of evidence, there is strong evidence based on reports of observable ivermectin benefit to profylaxis and some benefit in treatmeant of early infections.
- dang 5y agoPlease don't cross into flamewar, especially on divisive topics. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- effie 5y agoOK I could have worded that better, but I certainly did not want to get into a flamewar. I think there is a well visible point there still.
- wumpus 5y agoIt would be nice to make a list of things that appeared to work in hospitals and then failed randomized trials.
- javagram 5y agoHydroxychloroquine is a good example. Lots of doctors were trying it and thought it seemed to help. Due to the interest in the drug several RCTs of it were performed and it was shown to have no effect on patient recovery or prophylaxis of covid.
- codeflow2202 5y agoThis is just partially true. The studies you mention are on late treatment (and often on very high dosages). The data points to good efficacy for early treatment though. It seems clear that the only use for HCQ is during the viral multiplication phase which is not what the large studies have been looking into (they never look into early treatment for some reason).
- forgingahead 5y agoThis isn't true. A recent study showed significant results in using HCQ: https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/throat-spray-and-hydroxychloroquine-found-to-reduce-risk-of-covid-19-infection https://www.straitstimes.com/singapore/health/throat-spray-a...
- xattt 5y agoAre there any specific “trench innovations” that come to mind?
- raphlinus 5y agoThe thing that most immediately comes to mind is Cameron Kyle-Sidell, who recognized that the standard treatment protocols were over-intubating people for hypoxemia, and that overly high pressures of ventilators were causing damage. He faced a great deal of resistance within his institution at the time, and was quite controversial in taking his case to Twitter and Youtube. Since then, he's been vindicated, and protocols have been changed. I post this because I think it's the exception that proves the rule. Dr. Kyle-Sidell is a physician of great perception and insight. For every one of him, there are no doubt hundreds of "hydroxychloroquine doctors" who peddle bullshit without scientific basis to the harm of their patients. But the existence of doctors like him does boost the "maverick doctor bucking the institution" narrative. [1]: https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/928156 https://www.medscape.com/viewarticle/928156 [2]: https://elemental.medium.com/how-one-covid-19-doctor-became-a-ventilator-whistleblower-a1c2dbdd1b06 https://elemental.medium.com/how-one-covid-19-doctor-became-...
- ipaddr 5y agoThese days youtube would ban him.
- rossjudson 5y agoHow do you know that?
- pbak 5y agoHave you read the headline ? They banned an interview with the inventor of mRNA vaccine tech for saying it might be dangerous and needs more caution and study.
- foolinaround 5y ago> "hydroxychloroquine doctors" who peddle bullshit without scientific basis as of today, the mechanism that made HCQ work has been explained scientifically, right? What is your bias regarding this? Now, that the mechanism is better understood, the doctor who recommended HCQ has now moved on to a better suggestion utilizating the same mechanism.