5 ms·
I have an original Prusa Mini I upgraded to the Mini+. I ordered it and it arrived in December 2019. Like other Prusa Minis, it comes with an "appendix" you mus
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
I have an original Prusa Mini I upgraded to the Mini+. I ordered it and it arrived in December 2019. Like other Prusa Minis, it comes with an "appendix" you must physically break to be able to install unsigned firmware. And, of course, breaking the appendix voids the warranty and drops all liability on the part of the manufacturer. My warranty has long expired but I haven't broken it yet.
Personally, I think that in this era of Hardware Root of Trust devices and locked bootloaders, if we were to try to prevent such devices from existing, I think the appendix is a fairly brilliant solution that could be applied elsewhere.
For example, my iPhone. Apple doesn't allow side-loading because, well, they're afraid Facebook or Epic would force users to side-load against their will, among other business reasons. But if they were legally mandated to offer an appendix that could be snapped to enable sideloading, it would hopefully keep Facebook at bay (there's no way Facebook can convince people broadly to do such a thing), and would satisfy us hardware hackers.
It's still not perfect, but I think it could be an excellent "first step" in unlocking these devices that, among many solutions, could potentially be bipartisan and harder for tech companies to argue against.
- smoldesu 5y agoI mostly think the "appendix" system works, but I think the first party should still assume limited liability for the hardware of the device after the appendix is broken, so they still have an incentive not to conspire against their users. Furthermore: > Apple doesn't allow side-loading because, well, they're afraid Facebook or Epic would force users to side-load against their will, among other business reasons. I think "other business reasons" are the bigger issue here. Facebook and Epic wouldn't "force" users to side-load content any more than Apple "forces" you to use the App Store on iOS. It's an available option that you can use at your own discretion. Apple (unlike Prusa) has painted themselves into a pretty favorable corner. They've made their value proposition immaterial, which allows them to pretty easily deflect any accusations that their 30% cut is out of line. Apple has full control over the goalposts here: they could claim that their cut goes to hosting alone or covers the entirety of the review process.
- R0b0t1 5y ago> I mostly think the "appendix" system works, but I think the first party should still assume limited liability for the hardware of the device after the appendix is broken, so they still have an incentive not to conspire against their users. The seller can not absolve themselves of liability in this way. They still assume liability under their warranty and must prove changes you made are the cause of malfunction even if you modify the device. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty...
- mike_d 5y agoUS law does not apply to a business in the Czech Republic. But even if it was in the US, what you are citing mostly applies to things like cars that you can put aftermarket parts on. They could just say that modifying the firmware is "[using] a product for something other than its intended purpose" and the FTC will just look at you and shrug.
- 7steps2much 5y agoIn the EU you actually have something similar. You have the warranty given by the merchant, which can be voided by breaking stickers, appendixes, etc. and the legal warranty (in German it is called Gewährleistung) which cannot be voided by stickers or tricks like this. However, if you want to invoke your legal warranty more than 6 months after purchase date YOU have to prove that your modifications didn't cause the defect.
- oneplane 5y agoSame in The Netherlands. Works perfectly fine, especially since you have a reasonable period in which the effort slowly moves over to the owner. In a mass-quality-deficiency case you could still find an easy way with other owners to create the proof you need and still get the manufacturer to be responsible, so if such a case were to occur it's still reasonable.
- 5y ago
- R0b0t1 5y agoBreaking the appendix does not void your warranty. The seller must prove your modifications broke the device. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magnuson%E2%80%93Moss_Warranty...
- germanier 5y agoThey are not a US company nor do they operate from within the US at all. That law does not apply to their warranty.
- lostapathy 5y agoThey do trade shows here, at least before the pandemic, so they do have some exposure to US laws.
- tssva 5y agoThey market to US customers, sell to US customers and process payments through US financial institutions, so legally they operate in the US. Just as Prusia himself is protected by GDPR protections from US companies which offer services to citizens of EU even if they aren't physically located there.
- germanier 5y agoHonestly, I'm not well versed in US law but as far as I understand, you need to show nexus to apply it which has totally different and much more nuanced criteria compared to the GDPR (which simply spells those out)
- R0b0t1 5y agoYou need to show nexus mostly for tax related matters. If you are slighted by a foreign company you can still receive a judgement against them or their functionaries, and in extreme matters the company and its distributors would start having issues with CBP and with their banks. The damages required for such issues can be quite high, $50-75k for federal court filing, but existing precedent would allow you to go after distributors in a local court for a lower amount.
- jrockway 5y ago> it would hopefully keep Facebook at bay (there's no way Facebook can convince people broadly to do such a thing) I bet Facebook would be able to get users to do it. "Sorry, you can't see this photo from your friend until you upgrade your iPhone by following these instructions." You refuse and your friends stop including you in activities. You basically get peer pressured into doing what a large corporation says. (I actually wonder why they don't sell peer pressure as a service. "If you don't pay your balance due of $123.45 by 7/1, we'll message your friends saying that you're a deadbeat." Maybe I should patent that before someone else does, because it sounds horrible.)
- martey 5y ago> (I actually wonder why they don't sell peer pressure as a service. "If you don't pay your balance due of $123.45 by 7/1, we'll message your friends saying that you're a deadbeat." Maybe I should patent that before someone else does, because it sounds horrible.) Alas, this is not a new idea: - https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2010/11/facebook-warns-debt-collectors-about-using-its-service/66831/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2010/11/faceb... - https://restofworld.org/2020/okash-microlending-public-shaming/ https://restofworld.org/2020/okash-microlending-public-shami... - https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/can-a-debt-collector-contact-me-through-facebook/ https://www.experian.com/blogs/ask-experian/can-a-debt-colle... - https://www.theguardian.com/money/2021/may/09/loan-sharks-target-new-victims-via-whatsapp-and-facebook https://www.theguardian.com/money/2021/may/09/loan-sharks-ta...
- tudorw 5y agoIn Spain it's somewhat of a tradition, they have fun costumes though so... https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/boom-time-spain-s-costumed-debt-collectors-922500.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/europe/boom-time-sp...
- g8oz 5y agoIn a similar spirit https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/jun/08/pakistan-hijra-transgender-tax-collectors https://www.theguardian.com/world/2012/jun/08/pakistan-hijra...
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoThe iPhone is so valuable and an unlocked one would have so much unique value that an industry would pop up modding customer phones and also selling modded phones. The average consumer would think “oh yeah don’t buy from Apple buy from these folks” and it would become common for people to have the devices.
- easton 5y agoChromeOS devices also have something like this in the form of the write-protect screw. https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromiumos/docs/+/HEAD/write_protection.md#Hardware-Write-protect https://chromium.googlesource.com/chromiumos/docs/+/HEAD/wri...
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y ago> they're afraid Facebook or Epic would force users to side-load against their will, As an Apple user, this is my biggest fear about allowing other App stores. Facebook, etc hate Apple’s privacy policies, but the iPhone market is too big and too rich to ignore. If now they can tap the iPhone market without having to deal with Apple’s privacy requirements, I am sure they would be delighted. Soon, they would at least have more features in the side-loaded version to try to push people towards it. The companies like Epic and Facebook would have saved money by this move, but I as a privacy minded consumer, would have lost.
- sneak 5y agoThis is user choice at work. The only thing that can address this issue is free software that users can modify easily.
- userbinator 5y agoLike other Prusa Minis, it comes with an "appendix" you must physically break to be able to install unsigned firmware. In the same way as warranty seals, this sort of stuff can usually be worked around with not a lot of effort. One of the comments there already mentions: You can test if the "appendix" is the issue by connection BOOT0 and SWDIO to GND. That is all the appendix does. "There's a few thousand mice but only one cat." "What you can make, we can break."
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoThe point is that you must physically remove it or severe the traces, which is then obvious if the device is returned for a refund or warranty claim. It’s not meant to be complicated. It’s only meant to be easily identified during the RMA process.
- userbinator 5y agoThe point is that it can be done relatively easily, and reversibly. Of course, it probably does act as a filter for low-effort scams.
- rasz 5y ago> breaking the appendix voids the warranty no it doesnt, at least not in US (magnusson moss) https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/04/11/601582169/warranty-void-if-removed-as-it-turns-out-feds-say-those-warnings-are-illegal https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2018/04/11/601582169...
- oneplane 5y agoPretty much anywhere in the world, we are not in the US (except when you are, in the US) so that's great for the US but doesn't apply here.