2 ms·
I have seen some economists say that the best corporate tax would, ironically, be 0% Corporate Tax. Why should we double-tax income with Corporate Tax and then
by gjsman-1000 5y ago
I have seen some economists say that the best corporate tax would, ironically, be 0% Corporate Tax. Why should we double-tax income with Corporate Tax and then Income Tax when it goes to individuals? Plus, the corporate tax tends to cause all sorts of shenanigans.
And this isn't a radical idea. Both right-wing and left-wing publications (such as The Washington Post) have proposed it.
- HWR_14 5y agoWhy is "double-taxation" bad? What act do you think should be taxed where it is being taxed twice? > The Washington Post) have proposed it. Leaving aside the idea that a paper owned by the world's richest man (with unrealized billions in gains) is neutral on the topic of taxation can you cite this?
- zdragnar 5y agoCorporate taxes directly impact consumers and employees. Corporations just increase prices or cut costs to manage it... Or, if they are multinational, play accounting shenanigans and choose not to remit money back to the US.
- rsj_hn 5y ago> Why is "double-taxation" bad? It's not that double-taxation is bad but people are claiming that corporate profits aren't taxed or are taxed at very low rates (I've heard people use numbers like 5%) and so need to be taxed more on general fairness grounds. Pointing out that they are already taxed negates that argument. In general, all "fairness" arguments (this tax is "bad") to taxation are quite awful, because they tend to be made by people who have no idea of what the actual incidence of taxation is. (Really most fairness arguments of any kind are awful and suffer from similar problems about people not understanding the consequences of their proposals and thus not being qualified to decide on what is fair and what is not). For example the same people enthusiastically argue for taxes on corporations but not sales taxes, when these have the same incidendence and thus are the same tax. The difference is primarily one of shifting the burden of who fills out the paperwork and a lot of marketing. And that tendency to view taxation on grounds of fairness (e.g. emotion) rather than economic concerns (the ultimate cost of the tax) is what opens the door to massive tweaks of the tax code by various lobbyists. A simpler tax code that treated all sources of income in the same way and did not distinguish between expenditures would be a much better system than we have now. No tax deductions for any purpose and no separate treatment of wage or capital income, or inheritance income, etc. Just put it all into one pile and apply the tax rate for that pile. Similarly consolidate all corporate and sales taxes together into a single VAT that does not distinguish by industry or product type. Then if the government wants to give money for fab construction (a foolish policy, IMO) they can do that directly. It would be great if we had taboos against tweaking the tax code entirely.
- epistasis 5y agoI think double taxation is a fantastic thing, it allows far more granular taxation. However, I also think we need a land tax, and part of that land tax includes the economic land of intellectual property. IP is one of the biggest roadblocks for new entrants to the space, which greatly limits expansion of production capacity. This is also very true for things like pharmaceuticals in the developing world. There's a tradeoff to be made between allowing the creators of new economic land to charge rent for the land, and the need to reduce that rent in order to improve economic efficiency.
- anonuser123456 5y agoI would love to see a compelling, good faith argument against the revenue neutral 0% corp tax rate. I've never seen a compelling counter argument.
- Taniwha 5y agoIf we're going to continue with the legal fiction that corporation's are 'people' and have the same rights as 'people' then they should also have the same responsibilities and we should tax them the same