7 ms·
What benefits is Texas seeing from the Sunset Commission? https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/ https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/ shows a lot of what appear to be wholly spurio
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
What benefits is Texas seeing from the Sunset Commission? https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/ https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/ shows a lot of what appear to be wholly spurious licensing types:
- barbering
- cosmetology
- dietitians
- dyslexia therapy
- behavior analysts
- polygraph examiners (!)
- auctioneers
- etc. etc.
- brianwawok 5y agoWhy should these not be licensed? A dietitian giving bad advice could cause serious harm. A dyslexia therapist could provide no benefit to the patient. A cosmetologist could cause someone's hair to fall out. Like, having something deeper than yelp reviews to help make someone's hair not fall out seems reasonable...
- silverpepsi 5y agoYou don't have enough personal experience perhaps to know licensing is more about power and protectionist rakets than the claimed purpose. My dad was a doctor who lost his license (nothing dramatic or gossip-worthy involved). He was primarily treating opiate addicts with something called Suboxone. It is sensitive enough that the state puts a hard limit on patients you can have - 100. This means people who need the treatment are often on waiting lists because the doctors who have the qualification to write Suboxone are often at their 100 patient limit. Father told the medical board they need to find placements for his 100 patients or they will end up dead WITH ABSOLUTE CERTAINTY. Medical board couldn't give two shits since that's not their problem, last we know at least three died within 4 months or so of not being able to find a new doctor.
- specialist 5y agoThe solution to regulatory capture is to abolish regulations?
- brianwawok 5y agoRight. Specific regulations can be bad and implemented poorly. That is a far jump from no regulations.
- EricE 5y agolol - the problem is these laws restrict far more than they help. Just look at AB-5 in CA - lobbyist driven legislation full of unintended consequences that, amusingly, bit a lot of people in the press (who were pushing it) in the ass since it severely limited what they could do as a freelancer vs. an employee. All the other licensing requirements do is favor incumbents and restrict competition. Amazon was against paying local sales taxes - until they eventually figured it out; now they are a huge proponent for forcing all online retailers to have to collect all local taxes. Will squeeze out the little guys or drive them into their web store solutions. Regulations rarely benefit small business or their customers. Also who seriously pays attention to if someone has a license or not? You can still get a bad haircut or advice from a licensed person. What I find appalling is the more rigorous the licensing the less some people question the people who hold them. Indeed, it's now a thing to criticize any critical thinking around "experts" (such as the anointed one, Saint Fauci) - utterly disgusting.
- WalterBright 5y agoThe initial motivation for the licensing of medical doctors was to put minority doctors out of business. See "Competition and Monopoly in Medical Care" by Frech.
- frankus 5y agoThe requirement to have a license for these types of fields is reasonable. What tends to happen, however, is that the requirements to acquire a license grow beyond basic health and safety to include a ton of formal education. This is probably due in part to the fact that practitioners are well represented among the people designing the licensing requirements, and they have a vested interest in erecting and maintaining barriers to new entrants. For example, it typically takes 1,500 hours of instruction to become licensed to cut peoples hair in exchange for money. That amount of training might be reasonable for someone working with potentially harmful chemicals, but on the other hand I can give someone a pretty decent buzzcut and have approximately zero hours of training (but would still face civil penalties if I were to open Frankus' Buzzcut Studio). It's also worth noting that licensing doesn't necessarily have to be enforced by the state, (although I agree that basic knowledge of the health and safety aspects of an occupation is probably a reasonable requirement to be state-enforced). You could have a private credentialing agency that certifies practitioners who have completed additional study or exams, or have a certain minimum amount of experience (something along the lines of Microsoft's MCSE credential, but for, say, applying makeup).
- hellbannedguy 5y agoThat's fine, but require 0 dollars for the license, and yearly fee. I sometimes think they want to license everything because it brings in a fair amount of money in fees.
- yaitsyaboi 5y agoI don't see a lot of overlap here and don't understand how they're spurious. Yeah the polygraph one seem anachronistic, but if people still use them I appreciate the state trying to make sure the practitioners aren't more snake oil-y than the field at large.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> I appreciate the state trying to make sure the practitioners aren't more snake oil-y than the field at large. What do you imagine you're getting from hypothetical oversight? It is not theoretically possible to be more snake-oily than the field at large.
- bastawhiz 5y agoAcupuncture is snake oil, but I would very much prefer knowing that my acupuncturist has been checked out by someone qualified to check their skills. Just because it's snake oil doesn't mean that there are not expectations around its safety and application.
- Aerroon 5y agoThen go to one that has some kind of recommendation or badge of acupuncture quality. Why should the government do that?
- handrous 5y agoBecause then you need an acupuncture badge quality quality badge, and so on.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoThat implies that we currently need QA organizations who rate government licensure schemes on their accuracy and informativeness. How often have you checked for those? You've completely failed to distinguish a legal licensure scheme from an independent endorsement scheme.
- fencepost 5y agoDo they still require a license for strippers? I always thought it would be entertaining to be a Texas licensed exotic dancer.
- trentnix 5y agoThe commission requires the legislature to act. It doesn't prevent the legislature from acting irresponsibly. But at least that irresponsible act will have some names on it that voters might recognize.
- _Nat_ 5y ago> What benefits is Texas seeing from the Sunset Commission? https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/ https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/ shows a lot of what appear to be wholly spurious licensing types: [...] - dietitians [Their site](https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/diet/diet.htm https://www.tdlr.texas.gov/diet/diet.htm) says that: > The Dietitians program licenses and regulates dietitians in Texas. A license is required to use the titles "Licensed Dietitian" and "Provisionally Licensed Dietitian." A license is not required to use the titles "Dietitian" or "Nutritionist." Haven't checked the others, but at least that one seems pretty reasonable. Also, hospitals tend to have licensed-dietitians to handle stuff like making meal-plans for patients, which is apparently a more involved process than one might think, especially for patients with multiple complications.
- stevespang 5y agoWait till they add chimney sweep, topless dancer, and lap dancer - - - -
- bob1029 5y agoLooks like some of these might be going away soon. Check out HB1560: https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/87R/billtext/html/HB01560F.htm https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/87R/billtext/html/HB01560F...