4 ms·
> I think we need to take a much more nonjudgmental view of the human family Dunno; how many of us agree what makes a good family? "Is everyone there happier a
by h2odragon 5y ago
> I think we need to take a much more nonjudgmental view of the human family
Dunno; how many of us agree what makes a good family? "Is everyone there happier and healthier than they would be elsewhere?" would be my question, but a lot of people seem to assume a good family is one that looks like those portrayed on TV.
As for animals; I can speak firsthand of dog packs where junior males have a lot to do with caring for the young, especially the "raise the teenagers" stage. The females of that age tend to stand on dignity and want nothing to do with pups, but the males are willing to be chew toys.
- sonofhans 5y ago> ... but the males are willing to be chew toys. The perfectly describes a non-trivial amount of fatherhood for me — I’m a combination of a mobile jungle gym and a chew toy :D
- damagednoob 5y ago> how many of us agree what makes a good family? I think there are things we can broadly agree on. For example, reducing the number of single-parent families or general delinquency. Once we solve those types of issues, we can get into the relative minutae of things like screen time, etc.
- developer93 5y agoWhy is a single parent family alone a bad thing? I could see a case where a single caring parent could be much better than 2 negligent or abusive ones.
- damagednoob 5y agoSure, add 'limiting any amount of abusive parents' to the list too. I was coming from the point of view of 'all other things being equal', two parents are better than one.
- developer93 5y agoAh ok, I read it as more absolutist than that. You don't think for example that children should be taken into care because they have only 1 parent?
- compiler-guy 5y ago"All else being equal" is an implied assumption here. Yes, two abusive parents are worse than one good parent. But two good parents are better than one good parent. It is probably also the case that one good parent and one abusive parent is better than one abusive parent alone.
- balfirevic 5y ago> But two good parents are better than one good parent. What about 3?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kbelder 5y agoProbably better, if they're good. But I suspect that it's a lot harder to find n-way relationship that are long-term stable, the higher n goes.
- DangitBobby 5y agoWe don't have kids but I see this kind of behavior with my wife regarding the dog. When he gets zoomies or very playful, she's likely to see this energetic behavior as "being bad" and not something to engage with. Not sure how extensible my anecdote is to other people's situations but it mirrors my understanding of the treatment of boys in a school setting.
- developer93 5y agoI think in a school setting, you can't make allowances for the 1 kid who is stopping the rest from learning, so behaviour that might be tolerated by parents or in a 1;1 situation gets shut down. Just hypothesising, no direct experience.
- User23 5y agoMost people on the planet agree that the ideal family involves both parents in a loving stable relationship who are able to provide for their children’s needs.
- zrail 5y agoFascinating generalization over 7.8 billion people.
- asguy 5y agoHow about we generalize a different way: how many successful societies can you name, that became successful while pushing single-parent child rearing?
- williamdclt 5y agoYou implicitely changed the criteria though: you went from the "ideal family", which is very vague but I would understand as "a family where the members are happy in their lives", to "a family model that makes a society successful". Optimising for the individual's happiness or for society "success" conceivably yields different family models.
- User23 5y agoIt’s a bit of a brutalization of the concept of ideal to reduce it to mere happiness. The junkie on his way to a fentanyl overdose may very well be happy, but nobody who is honest and not evil would hold it up as an ideal life. It’s pretty obvious that an ideal has to account for externalities to be much of one.
- borski 5y agoBut “success” is a fleeting metric, is the point. In your meth use example, the addiction and codependency are due to a physical dependency. Child-rearing is a choice, not a physical addiction. Can’t compare apples and oranges. Happiness is measured in happiness. We can also measure health. But “success” is too subjective to matter as a useful metric.
- steve_adams_86 5y agoSometimes I wonder if we focus too much on the human family and not enough on the human community. As someone raising kids in a city with no community network, no family around, etc - I am acutely aware that it's quite bad for my kids despite my ongoing best efforts. A supportive community can enrich life so much in ways that an isolated nuclear family probably can't. It can offer things parents can't themselves. So in isolation, sure, let's talk about what the best family structure can be and we will certainly discover important things. But I think it has to be one which integrates well socially, and allow community in. Without that there is a lot of lost potential. Just my opinion of course. Perhaps this mostly reflects my own inadequacies, I'm not sure.