4 ms·
I don't want to go into this topic because frontend developers are very defensive of their capability to Javascript on people, they often cite javascript adopti
by dijit 5y ago
I don't want to go into this topic because frontend developers are very defensive of their capability to Javascript on people, they often cite javascript adoption numbers as proof that it's fine to make it mandatory or cite complex web applications as a reason for it to be mandatory for all sites, which I personally find to be a false dichotomy.
I tend to agree with what you're saying but the ship has sailed very much and running without javascript is a losing proposition these days.
(my web browser starts up with javascript disabled except for some whitelisted sites and it usually only takes 15 minutes for me to find something completely broken on the internet and re-enable javascript entirely).
- sneak 5y agoNah. I browse the web with NoScript. Snowden himself says to disable scripting in browsers.
- voakbasda 5y agoEntirely? Use NoScript to temporarily enable only those portions of the single site that you need. No affiliation, just a happy user.
- SkyMarshal 5y ago/second NoScript. Instead of whitelisting whole sites, you can whitelist links to JavaScript imports across all sites, temporarily or permanently. So for example, you can whitelist urls to all the major JavaScript frontend frameworks’ CDNs, like bootstrap, etc. while leaving known trackers and spyware blacklisted by default. Anecdotally it seems most websites still work with their trackers disabled, as long as they have their frontend framework/s loaded.
- gruez 5y agoI disagree. There are way too many sites that require javascript that you'll eventually get into the habit of blindly enabling scripts when a site breaks, negating any security benefits.
- hutzlibu 5y agoYou probably misunderstood : allmost all websites require javascript, yes - but you can selectivly allow only the javascript of that site, their framework etc. and block all the tracker/ads javascript with NoScript/UBlock - and then it is working and probably quite safe. But to mitigate, more and more websites find ways to sneak in the tracker/ads/analytics into the main sites js. So it is not as easy, either. Which is why I just use basic ublock origin and regulary wipe the browser cache.
- gruez 5y ago>but you can selectivly allow only the javascript of that site, their framework etc. and block all the tracker/ads javascript with NoScript/UBlock What's the difference between that and just using the standard easylist/easyprivacy filter? I suppose there's a small chance that a third party site went rogue and isn't on the default lists, but I'm skeptical how many attacks that would thrawt in reality. The attacks I heard of tend to be first party/supply chain (would be white listed by you), or delivered through an ad network (probably already be on a blacklist).
- SkyMarshal 5y agoEasylist and Privacylist are great. I suppose the main reasons for doing it manually are seeing firsthand what all the sites you visit are doing behind the scenes, and getting a sense of what is legitimately needed functionality, what isn't, and what is just downright sketchy.
- hutzlibu 5y agoYup. But you can only do this when you have time for it. I kind of got very pragmatic with it.
- beebeepka 5y agoI've been using noscript for at least a decade and it hasn't happened yet. I have conditioned my wife to use it too. She doesn't do it either
- alisonkisk 5y agouMatrix by uBlock Origin too.
- dijit 5y agoI use a browser called Qutebrowser which doesn't have a noscript addon; but I can disable javascript loading on a domain level. However, overall I can tell you for absolute certain: if you have JS partially disabled things break in non-obvious ways and I find myself playing whack-a-mole with allowing various domains to load javascript to get the page working. I'm pretty certain you do also, because it's basically impossible to tell why certain damned sites are broken and the most obvious thing to do is just enable JS temporarily to see if it works at all. This is especially annoying on some part of a site such as checkout- where reloading the page causes a form resubmission.
- alisonkisk 5y agoI like this breakage because it makes me unhappy with the website and less likely to use it -- the immune system is working as it should.
- KronisLV 5y agoThat's probably a good approach for random news sites and such, much less so when your internet banking and even online shopping sites require JS on.
- lanstin 5y agoIf the actual payment is via Paypal I think it usually works without JavaScript in the merchant. And like content, there is no shortage of places to buy stuff. For banking i use their phone app or else visit them in person. But I use a credit union not a bank as I want to trust the people holding my money.