5 ms·
What is engineering other than expressing an opinion? Engineers are trained to have expert opinions. They are expected to consider all relevant factors. In A
by brudgers 5y ago
What is engineering other than expressing an opinion?
Engineers are trained to have expert opinions.
They are expected to consider all relevant factors.
In AEC the relevant factors include compliance with relevant laws and rules such as the building codes and all the documents incorporated by reference.
It is a matter of life safety and the regulation of construction is at least as old as the Code of Hammurabi…it predates the first amendment by three millennia.
In that context an unlicensed person holding themselves out as an expert in engineering has disregarded a basic responsibility, they have ignored a relevant legal requirement: their license.
This raises a legitimate concern. What other corners might they have cut for their own benefit?
Because ignoring licensure is to no one’s benefit but the person doing so. It is a violation of the trust people expect when engaging with engineers. The trust that the engineer will be objective in relevant matters.
Licensing engineers is why you don’t worry when you drive across a bridge…or under one. Or go up a tall building or stand next to it. It’s why collapsed bridges are news.
- mindslight 5y agoNo, an engineer without a Professional Engineer license is not "cutting corners". They most likely just don't do the type of work that requires getting a PE. The article says 80% of engineers are working without a license. From experience, this is especially true for electrical engineering. Someone designing a building's electrical system would have a PE to sign off on plans (or be working under someone with a PE). But someone doing embedded design would not, because there is a completely different approval process for consumer/industrial products - we test rather than simply asserting products are safe because they were designed by a PE. Without a PE, I am still an engineer. I can say I am an engineer, because "engineer" is not a protected title anywhere in the US. I can speak authoritatively on engineering topics, because I have vast technical knowledge. My opinions on topics I know little about (eg civil engineering) will be tempered with "I think", because knowing one area really well, I am aware of how much I do not know in other areas. Whether anyone chooses to listen to anything I say is their own choice. What I cannot do is sign off on plans for permits, solicit business that would generally require signing off on plans for permits, or anything else that specifically requires a PE license. Those requirements are in legal force due to the product delivered (eg a bridge requisitioned by the state, a house which needs a building permit) and are not generally applicable for all engineering activity. There also is the related issue that everybody has the right to technically criticize a situation if they have done the work to make their case. Only a licensed Professional Engineer has the ability to say a bridge is safe, but we all have the right to claim that it is unsafe.
- brudgers 5y agoThe person subject to the complaint prepared stormwater calculations and submitted it as evidence in a legal proceeding. The letter that person received from the board is linked in the article. It states the person is charged and gives them the opportunity for a written response. Civil engineering typically requires a PE.
- mindslight 5y agoEngineering generally refers to design and building, of which analysis is a single part. So it's not immediately apparent that Nutt was practicing engineering at all. It's more accurate to say that the kind of projects civil engineers work on generally end up requiring a PE, as a condition of actually being built. Small time civil engineering in your own backyard does not require a PE - eg improving drainage, setting up a windmill, building a chicken coop, etc. Prohibiting people from applying mathematical formulas in court arguments because doing so is "engineering" is a dangerous idea. If you're fighting a speeding ticket, is it "engineering" to independently calculate your speed by measuring the time between two points? Ultimately if the stormwater calculations are complex enough that the court is unable to follow them itself, then it is up to the court to disregard his testimony because he is not a professional engineer with a trustable opinion. That would be a perfectly reasonable outcome here. But what the state board is attempting to do is to prohibit anybody from examining technicalities without the right license. That's the path to closed society madness.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brudgers 5y agoHere the practice of engineering is specifically set out in statute, regulation, and legal precedent. As are the duties of the board, its process, penalties for violations, and appeals processes. The board is investigating a case based on its authority. The authority exists via democratic process originating with the legislative process and state constitution. The regulation of engineering is within the scope of the states per the US Constitution and established legal precedent.
- antiterra 5y ago1. This particular engineer worked legally as an engineer for DuPontt due to an industrial exception and was not required to license. There was no corner cut. 2. There is some precedent implying a free speech concern: https://reason.com/2019/01/02/judge-confirms-that-oregon-engineer-has/ https://reason.com/2019/01/02/judge-confirms-that-oregon-eng...
- brudgers 5y agoMy understanding is the events that sparked the investigation were outside of the subject’s workplace/employment. Hence “retired.” The preponderance of precedent favors the board’s concerns and right to investigate. Being slightly familiar with North Carolina professional regulations, I suspect this holds true at the state level in particular. The legal argument is inconsistent. It claims that the regulations don’t apply because the regulations apply via the industrial exemption in the regulations…never mind the retired.
- antiterra 5y agoThe first point addressed the suggest that any engineer who didn’t get their license must be suspect and is cheating the rules. You seem to have missed the legal argument in the Oregon case which had nothing to do with an industrial exemption.
- mcguire 5y ago"The first point addressed the suggest that any engineer who didn’t get their license and testified as an engineering expert witness must be suspect and is cheating the rules." Nutt became required to get a license when he began practicing engineering outside the "industrial exception".
- antiterra 5y agoI guess we disagree that making an argument backed up with engineering while clearly not misrepresenting himself is ‘practicing engineering.’ That argument, however, is somewhat covered by the proceedings of the Oregon case.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoWhy is a license more important than skill and experience? So you’ll trust a person that’s failed the license multiple times, is barely able to do the job, and has a history of failing at their job because they have a license? Because those issues still happen with licensed professionals. A license doesn’t prove aptitude, it just proves you passed a test. I’ve met multiple structural engineers that relied heavily on computer software for validation because they couldn’t understand calculus
- brudgers 5y agoThe person without a license who is doing something that requires a license is not taking full responsibility for what they are doing. They are doing something that is only to their own benefit in a context where other people’s lives are at stake. Quite simply it is unprofessional. A person without a license can hire a licensed professional for oversight. That’s the responsible thing to do. In the US, engineering licensure requires supervised experience, testing, and typically (but not always) formal education at the bachelor level. One requirement of professional practice is not working beyond one’s competence irrespective of having a license and engineering boards take that seriously. I guess that’s the thing, an unlicensed person doing unsupervised work requiring a license is some combination of incompetent, unqualified, or negligent. To put it another way, licensure ensures that a person has a minimum amount of skill, training, and experience. And that they take responsibility.
- jbluepolarbear 5y agoBut who decides it needs a license? Other licensed individuals? I would do a better job sticking to requirements than a lot of licensed engineers. It’s cheaper and easier for me to do all the work, and then hire a firm to say it passes requirements than getting said license. It gives me the freedom to engineer in any field I’m interested. I have previously done mechanical, electrical, structural, and medical engineering. How would a license help me? It’s waste years of my life, tons of money, jobs in don’t want, and at the end of it I can work in a field I may no longer want to be in.
- 5y ago