4 ms·
No opinion on whether this is a new development or not, but needing a license to talk about engineering is really stupid. By far the majority of engineering wor
by roenxi 5y ago
No opinion on whether this is a new development or not, but needing a license to talk about engineering is really stupid. By far the majority of engineering work is stating the obvious. Even a novice with some calculus background could probably come to the right answer if they had access to the necessary data. Maybe they'd need a little help warming up. Engineers are just more reliable at getting to the obvious answer, and have made enough mistakes that they double check their calculations.
Licensing laws used against people are more likely to be used for political cover rather than to protect the public.
- cesaref 5y agoIt would make learning to be an engineer pretty difficult, if you can't talk about stuff until you are qualified!
- blfr 5y agoNeeding a license to talk about anything is really stupid. We have seen credentialed experts trip time and again, succumb to industry pressure, form outright lobbies hostile to public interest. While there is some value in credentials for quick judgements and floor requirements, there is never an honest reason to bar someone from giving their opinion or testifying. Everyone is always free to not listen or disregard that opinion.
- taneq 5y agoIt depends very much on precisely what you're talking about. Someone giving an opinion on a physical system? Absolutely should not be regulated. Someone giving engineering advice and representing that advice as the result of rigorous analysis and themselves as an authority on the topic? I can see an argument for regulating that. We place similar expectations on legal and medical advice, and wrong engineering advice is arguably more dangerous than both. (For values of 'engineering' involving 'building heavy machinery, physical infrastructure, etc. which lives depend on - a wrong diagnoses can kill one person, a bad load calc can potentially kill thousands if a stadium collapses. I don't mean giving advice on page layout in CSS needs to be regulated.) Edit: Note that I'm not saying he should be gagged, and the circumstances definitely need to be considered, just that I understand the reasoning behind standards for advice presented as authoritative. What's going on in TFA more smacks of union protectionism than genuine caution.
- blfr 5y agoWe place similar expectations on legal and medical advice We do and received terrible medical advice during the latest pandemic while people trying to correct it were getting banned from social media. We are also reaping results of decades of terrible dietary advice. The track record for censorship isn't great.
- morelisp 5y agoYou're right, the unregulated dietary supplements market looks so much better!
- blfr 5y agoYou're trying to mock my comment but schizoid posters on twitter pushing their supplements often do have better dietary advice than USDA. The bar set by credentialed experts is so low, people who likely belong in an institution can clear it.
- logicchains 5y agoUnregulated dietary supplements have killed way fewer people than obesity.
- taneq 5y agoAlso very good points. The WHO in particular should face heavy criticism for their early handling (or non-handling) of the COVID-19 pandemic. Pretty much everything they said for the first 3 months was about as wrong and harmful as it was possible to be, and seemed entirely driven by political rather than health considerations. The dietary advice thing is mental the deeper you look into it, too. Breakfast is the most important meal of the day! Wait, it was Kelloggs saying that. More than two eggs a day will make you die of heart disease? Apparently not any more. Was that dodgy advice from the pork board or did Big Egg just buy off the right people? Fat is bad for you and makes you fat, says CSR. Actually sugar makes you fat AND causes cancer, but dietary fat is fine, says Brownes Dairy.
- prepend 5y agoI think the issue is he gave expert testimony. So it’s not just speaking about it, but presenting from a position of authority without qualification. I think the whole expert testimony business is suspect as the definition of “expert” varies so much. But I think the correction is in the law specifying what is expect and not and making that better is the place to focus. It seems like the correction would be to invalidate his testimony, not to arrest him. It’s really hard to have legal expert testimony and separate true experts vs people with other motivators (money, family, etc).
- civilized 5y ago> presenting from a position of authority without qualification. You mean, "presenting from a position of expertise without very specific and questionably relevant credentials demanded by a local regulatory body." His education and career experience are certainly qualifications substantiating his expertise. From the OP: > “In this country, we rely on people to decide who they want to listen to rather than relying on the government to decide who gets to speak,” said IJ Attorney Joe Gay. “North Carolina’s engineering board is getting that important principle exactly backwards.” Amen, brother. For a state or local entity to curtail First Amendment rights, they must have a compelling interest in doing so. There is very little reason to believe that passing tests administered by the local engineering board actually provides any protective value to the public in a context where the person in question is merely criticizing a design (not building anything) and already has extensive hands-on experience in the subject they are speaking on. It's quite possible that, in cases like this, licensing demands mostly exist for the Board to arrogate power and money to itself. The Board must clear a much higher bar to legally punish people for speech.
- SeanLuke 5y agoBeing a licensed engineer is not a requirement to being an "expert" in expert testimony. You are an expert if the court deems you an expert and the opposing counsel has agreed. Full stop. I think that the only thing an engineering license should grant you, in this case, is the right to call yourself a licensed engineer, which conveys some degree of authority. I don't think he made that claim.
- mcguire 5y ago"...needing a license to talk about engineering is really stupid..." Not to "talk about engineering". To provide expert testimony as an engineer.