4 ms·
Who is ultimately at risk because of Spectre and Meltdown? What additional risks am I taking on by disabling mitigations?
by nerdponx 5y ago
Who is ultimately at risk because of Spectre and Meltdown? What additional risks am I taking on by disabling mitigations?
- dijit 5y agoThe scope of the potential damage is rather huge and can't really be overstated. It's akin to handing over your entire working OS memory to a person, complete with all encryption keys, session tokens and whatever documents you're working on. Potentially, anyway. The working proof-of-concept attacks I've seen use a lot of CPU to read memory and they read slowly, but those are proof-of-concepts and it would not be terribly difficult for a motivated person to make them significantly faster and less obvious.
- thrower123 5y agoHas there ever been a real-world attack of this type? All kinds of things are possible, but you don't cut your leg off because theoretically you might possibly one day get gangrene from an ingrown toenail.
- mhh__ 5y agoI assume the triple letters have done it, but these attacks require a lot of careful planning so why bother when you can exploit something else. That kind of protects us, but these exploits are terrifying for purveyors of homogenous interfaces (i.e. the cloud) that can be attacked in ways you are already imagining. Also, anyone deploying this won't be stupid enough to chat.
- dijit 5y agoYes there are working proofs of concept using JavaScript for this kind of attack. https://leaky.page/ https://leaky.page/ Is a good example The proof of concept code has been further mitigated by removing high precision timers from JavaScript in most/all browsers; however it is not terribly difficult to create code which bypasses that restriction. The only thing that’s prevented more investment into this method of attack is that it has essentially no value due to everyone being immune.
- msbarnett 5y agoThere are working proof of concept attacks. The only reason you don’t hear more about this is that the mitigations being complained about here are universally enabled in the most vulnerable targets, like cloud hosts. Otherwise it would be pretty trivial to weaponize the original demonstration, deploy an image to AWS or Google Cloud and read out all your neighbours’ secrets. The success of the mitigations in rendering these attacks unworkable is literally the only reason people are under the mistaken impression that the cost of the mitigations isn’t worth it “because these attacks don’t happen”.
- mhh__ 5y agoMeltdown for example can exfiltrate data at a genuinely ridiculous rate, from any process (or at least any interesting ones). Spectre is more context dependent but Meltdown is egregious.
- MauranKilom 5y agoThose exploits enable any program to read essentially all memory. This means nothing you did between turning on your computer and running an application with potentially malicious code (e.g. looking at a website with javascript enabled) is secret.