5 ms·
They put a non-automotive grade LCD in Teslas. I assume because they thought they knew better. I suspect hubris is at play more than full-on incompetence.
by tyingq 5y ago
They put a non-automotive grade LCD in Teslas. I assume because they thought they knew better. I suspect hubris is at play more than full-on incompetence.
- willhinsa 5y agoJust curious, what are the differences between normal LCD's and automotive-grade LCD's?
- aaronmdjones 5y agoAutomotive-grade LCDs don't burn out and melt at the temperatures commonly found in ... well, automotive environments. Like your car sitting in a tarmac car park all day in sunny weather with the windows closed.
- tyingq 5y agoCertified operating temperature range would be one.
- kosievdmerwe 5y agoOne thing that was shocking to me when I looked this up myself is the temperature range of a car dashboard where the LCD is mounted. It can get ludicrously hot in the summer if the car is parked under the sun[1], like 80-90 C (180-200 F) hot. [1] https://www.clickorlando.com/news/2019/09/26/heres-how-hot-temperatures-can-get-in-your-car/ https://www.clickorlando.com/news/2019/09/26/heres-how-hot-t...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- driverdan 5y agoSpaceX and Tesla are separate companies with different employees. "They" did not put anything in Teslas.
- tyingq 5y agoSeparate companies with the same CEO, (some) shared board members, joint projects, cross sales of services and equipment, loans of employees, etc. Surely there's significant culture bleed.
- nine_k 5y agoI wish more of the SpaceX culture bled into Tesla then.
- rpmisms 5y agoMove faster, break more things? Tesla delivers far more refined products than SpaceX
- nine_k 5y agoYes, break more things on testing grounds. Keep iterating until the thing works well. SpaceX, paradoxically, has easier time experimenting and partially failing, because they mostly haul machines. Every Tesla car, OTOH, has a human pilot.
- zaroth 5y agoThe put a non-automotive grade LCD in the original Model S because it was that LCD or nothing. The automotive screens didn’t exist in the size they needed and they weren’t at a stage in their company where they could design their own. They took a risk to achieve the product vision that they were determined to bring into the world given the technical constraints of the age. I’d say overall it paid off. IMO it wasn’t arrogance.
- jsight 5y agoYeah, and their typical failure mode, yellowing around the edges, still looked better than a lot of other vehicles from its era. I don't like their handling of it from a warranty perspective, but I'm also not sure that their initial decision was actually the wrong one.
- da_chicken 5y agoI agree, it wasn't arrogance. Deliberately going forward with something in spite of knowing for certain that it's not fit for purpose is called engineering malfeasance, not arrogance.
- eganist 5y ago> Deliberately going forward with something in spite of knowing for certain that it's not fit for purpose is called engineering malfeasance, not arrogance. An argument can be made for both. Malfeasance in that it was a significant and potentially catastrophic engineering tradeoff due to unknown failure modes, and arrogant in that the decision valued company vision over potential consumer safety risks as well as over the expertise of the component manufacturers.
- MobiusHorizons 5y ago+1. This is something software engineers (of which I am one) often miss-understand about other engineering disciplines. You can totally ship software that you know will run into problems down the line, because you can reasonably expect to solve those challenges and ship updates before they come into play. But when you sell someone a durable good that is expected to last 10-20 years (eg a car) there are a whole host of things that go into designing that thing that are not ok to fix later. The result is that these engineering disciplines have practices that are much more rigorous. If you think about it, a recall is essentially a hardware patch, and they are typically highly embarrassing and costly. There is also the whole separate aspect of professional licensure which certain engineers get. Licensed engineers are expected to hold their work to certain standards regardless of the business needs of the company they work for. Now i'm not saying what Tesla did falls in this category, but it certainly looks like designing a product below the standard expected for that product. (what most people would call shoddy engineering). In software we often get away with this, because we can put in the work later on, and also because people often have insanely low expectations of how well software will work.
- tzs 5y agoI wonder if they are doing that for other components too, or just the LCD?
- rtkwe 5y agoIIRC there were issues with the flash memory in the media unit (afaik that means the whole giant center screen) where it would fail to boot after a while because the flash chips were failing. They actually issued a recall for that one at least.
- 0xTJ 5y agoI don't know, so this is a genuine question, but is that a safety-critical part in that case? If it's not it's still not ideal, you want to make sure that your parts will happily survive the car's environment, but it's not as bad.
- shakna 5y ago> Safety concerns revolve around cars losing their display for rear-facing cameras (now required by law) and consumers complaining it’s impossible to defog windshields with the center console inoperable. [0] > Another complaint said the failure disabled safety monitors associated with Tesla’s driver-assistance system Autopilot. [1] It looks like losing access to the touchscreen does actually effect safety components, and driver's abilities to use them. (Though I'm not clear on to what extent - driver's might just need to crack out the manual to see how else to defog, for example.) [0] https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2020/06/tesla-investigated-over-touchscreen-failure-complaints/ https://www.thetruthaboutcars.com/2020/06/tesla-investigated... [1] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-safety/u-s-probes-touchscreen-failures-in-tesla-model-s-cars-idUSKBN23V1VG https://www.reuters.com/article/us-tesla-safety/u-s-probes-t...
- brewdad 5y agoSafety critical? Who knows, but probably depending on how you want to define "safety critical." Tesla runs practically every user control through the touch screen. Climate control, lighting, wipers. Did they design with reasonable fail-safes? I wouldn't want to bet my life on it.