3 ms·
This project was a disaster, no matter how you slice it. It is very lucky that it failed only as much as it did. That it was down so much of the time made it wo
by ncmncm 5y ago
This project was a disaster, no matter how you slice it. It is very lucky that it failed only as much as it did. That it was down so much of the time made it worse than useless: expensive to build, expensive to operate, expensive to maintain, ruinously expensive to clean up after, and didn't even provide reliable baseload power.
The experience does not suggest that small-format nukes are simpler to operate and maintain than big ones.
There is no plausible scenario where small-format nukes are a better investment than a solar + wind + storage system, terrestrially. On Mars or the moon, leaks might not matter so much, although the catastrophic failure likely to follow would leave users without power.
Even with insolation on Mars much reduced, solar remains the overwhelmingly better choice by any measure.
On the moon, dark for two weeks at a stretch calls for more clever engineering. An 11,000 km equatorial superconducting transmission line with distributed solar panels could power quite a lot of activity. Even a 5500 km system would be immediately useful, given a vertically-oriented array at each end. But solar and storage would probably be cheaper. A flywheel constructed above-ground, hundreds of meters across (dumbell style, at first) would store quite a lot of energy. Structure could be just a cable on top of a tower; when stopped, the counterweights hang vertically, and swing out as it spins up.
https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2021/04/25/powering-the-lunar-base/#comment-5618 https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2021/04/25/powering-the-l...