3 ms·
Thanks for the thoughtful answer! IMHO: > seem plausible to me > someone took the time to explain to me (to my satisfaction) > I've asked about them, had the
by wolverine876 5y ago
Thanks for the thoughtful answer! IMHO:
> seem plausible to me
> someone took the time to explain to me (to my satisfaction)
> I've asked about them, had them confirmed as problems, and fixed them
Based on that, Wiktionary's standard of accuracy is what will be accepted by a non-expert. That's a pretty low standard; that's people talking in a college dorm room or in a bar. It's nothing personal - my intuitions on etymology are no better.
That's also how misinformation is created and spreads; it's right out of the textbook. Research shows that our intuitions about what's true are terrible if we don't have expertise in the issue, and that is how we are most easily fooled.
"The first principle is that you must not fool yourself -- and you are the easiest person to fool." - Richard Feynman
- jan_Inkepa 5y agoYeah as a non-expert I can only vouch so far. I can say that the time I did my deepest dive (about the various Latin words that look like 'pila' if you ignore vowel length, and their etymology - https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pila#Latin https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pila#Latin), using wiktionary as a starting point for trawling 'real' scholarly references I presented the work to my Latin teacher, a university professor of Ancient Greek, who said it checked out (though, he's a classicist and not a general linguist, so maybe that doesn't count. And maybe he was just humouring me). What we need is a linguist to get on here and give their take, and tell us how it fares compared to the professional resources.
- wolverine876 5y ago> What we need is a linguist to get on here and give their take, and tell us how it fares compared to the professional resources. Agreed. BTW, regardless of Wiktionary, I love the research - it's such creative, intriguing, stimulating work to explore those things. When people react, as (IMHO) they are conditioned to, to intellectual things with fear, hesitation and/or negativity, I think 'ugh, you are missing so much, the most beautiful things in this universe and many others.' And see my other comment about the OED. It's the best tool for it.