5 ms·
>"Again this is a semantics game, SNAP 10A was still driving a thermo electric converter, thus "scaled up RTG"" You are getting the absolute basics wrong, so y
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
>"Again this is a semantics game, SNAP 10A was still driving a thermo electric converter, thus "scaled up RTG""
You are getting the absolute basics wrong, so you have no standing to question the OP's atittude.
Nuclear reactor runs a nuclear chain reaction, hence the name, RTG does not. There is no scope for debate here. The difference is night and day and is obvious if you look at fuel, power to weight ratio, or do physics 101.
RTGs run on decay heat and use plutonium 238, they cant be turned off, their power slowly drops off over decades. Reactors use U235, have active control and starting/stop procedure and 10-100x higher power to weight
- Retric 5y agoThe issue is these designs are ~3% efficient like RTGs and have few moving parts unlike ~35% efficient nuclear reactors on earth. While they sidestep most of the complications of traditional nuclear reactors like radiation shielding, they really aren’t useful designs having low energy output, terrible energy density, relatively short lifespans, and extreme cost.
- mumblemumble 5y agoAccording to https://www.etec.energy.gov/Operations/Major_Operations/MajorOpsImages/SNAP_10A_Thermodynamic_cycle.jpg https://www.etec.energy.gov/Operations/Major_Operations/Majo... it's even worse than that; 1.83%. That said, it seems like, all by itself, conversion efficiency is a tricky measure of the usefulness of a design for spaceflight purposes. Wouldn't it be more useful to consider the total cost to deliver a given energy production capacity to space? In that case, rocket fuel itself, and the tyranny of the rocket equation, becomes a major consideration. If an efficiency gain comes at the cost of increasing the weight of the energy generation system in some way, then perhaps it doesn't end up being a net win over the less efficient design.
- Retric 5y agoEfficiency is a big deal in part because you need to radiate out all that thermal energy. A radiator that’s dumping 100kw of thermal energy for 1.3kw of electricity is much heavier than a 1.3kw solar panel anywhere near earth. Add 50kg for fuel and and things look even worse. By comparison the voyager probe RTG used ~1/10th the fuel for a little over 1/10th the power. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MHW-RTG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MHW-RTG So the only advantage was cheaper fuel.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThey have same radiation shielding and powet output as any other reactor, electricity generation is a separate concern that should not be confused with the reactor itself. The same reactor couod be hooked up to a 20% efficient stirling engine to keep it low maintenance, to a >50% efficient convined cycle or have 0% electricity output and be used for heat or water desalination.
- Retric 5y agoNuclear reactors aren’t plug and play, and you can sell they skipped a lot of radiation shielding simply from the weight of these systems. By comparison SL-1 a 400kw thermal design so 4x power used a 12,000 kg pressure vessel including shielding. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SL-1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SL-1