4 ms·
Honestly, good for them. TikTok is such a breath of fresh air in the social media space -- it's bursting with raw unfiltered creativity, interactions are really
by Spivak 5y ago
Honestly, good for them. TikTok is such a breath of fresh air in the social media space -- it's bursting with raw unfiltered creativity, interactions are really genuine and I've actually met now IRL friends on TikTok. Their recommendation engine is scary good at discovery which solves the "I don't know who to follow" problem, the ads are the least intrusive of any social media platform.
If you don't "get" TikTok because your hobbies don't map well to video snippets -- stuff like makeup, art, fashion, cooking, baking, dance, inde music, cosplay, interior decorating -- don't write it off. It's basically a social media paradise for women[1]. Like the early days of Tumblr but replace gifs with videos.
[1] TikTok's format lends itself to hobbies stereotypically cultivated by women. The implication doesn't go the other way; loads of guys on TikTok. It also doesn't imply that every woman will find like it; don't @ me with logical fallacies.
- xvector 5y agoTikTok creators are pushing out so much incredible OC. It feels like half of the Reddit front page are just TikTok reposts (with the logo censored out, because Redditors are too cool to admit they like TikTok content.)
- cwkoss 5y agoI think how the 'human centipede' of content works is really interesting as it has evolved over time. Creators coalese in certain apps and consumers others. 4 chan greentext used to be pretty common on Reddit a decade ago, and 9gag would repost reddit content. Twitter text often gets reposted to tiktok and reddit. Tiktok videos often get reposted to Twitter or Reddit. Heck, many major 'journalism' outfits now regularly include tweets - sometimes thats even the entire content of an article. /r/AmITheAsshole or similar long-form reddit posts are regularly read to make content for youtube or podcasts. In terms of original amateur-created content, seems the current winners of each medium are: - short form text: twitter - long form text: reddit - short video: tiktok - long video: youtube? but seems fragile
- xvector 5y ago> - long form text: reddit I would say Medium has taken over, here?
- ryandrake 5y agoI guess I still just don't get it. I'm always shocked at glowing recommendations of TikTok...from HN of all places! Every time it comes up here, I take a few minutes to browse the site, to see if anything changed to justify the praise, and it hasn't. The content may be more lighthearted, but over half of the random feed on the home page I just browsed is fundamentally the same "camera in your own face" narcissism amplifier as Instagram and the influencer portions of YouTube. I'm not even seeing a lot of hobbies there. It's just people who are not remarkably talented, but want to be in a video, making a video of themselves. It's got the same validation-seeker signals as the rest of social media (like count, comment count, share count). I browsed for about 30 minutes this morning so I could at least be informed before I comment, and literally found nothing remarkable or interesting. No unusual musical talents or athletics. Nothing really novel or even relatable. Just 20 year-old zeros making videos about themselves. Why is this a thing?
- bmarquez 5y agoI used to have the same arguments against TikTok, too many narcissist attention-seeking influencers. But TikTok's algorithm shows you videos partly based on how much time you spend looking at a video. So I started swiping to a new video immediately every time a selfie video showed up. The selfie videos mostly show up when you first create an account. The algorithm figured out I didn't like selfies so started showing me other random content, like travel, animals, etc. Then I started liking content I liked, so the algorithm gave me more of it. I finally have what I like and don't see any "20 year-old zeros making videos about themselves", but it took some time to set up. It's refreshing, and much more pleasurable than Facebook or Instagram which tries to show me political shares when I'm actively unfollowing politics.
- cwkoss 5y agoif you search for topics you're interested and like videos, the recommendation algorithm will shift fast. I used to never get 3dprinting vids until I searched for it and watched+liked a few, and now I get lots of them.
- justicezyx 5y ago> raw unfiltered creativity LMAO Those videos are literally produced by color or facial enhancement *filters*... Not to mention the content moderation and censorship...
- graphpapa 5y agoA figure of speech
- rvz 5y agoNo idea why you are downvoted, other than annoying the TikTok fanatics on this thread with "the facts" and a dose of reality that they seem to be trying to escape from by going into their own world of dancing short videos and community memes which is governed by another "recommendation algorithm" just like the rest of the other social networks out there. Nothing has changed. Even when there is strong evidence of this blatant censorship and suppression, they (TikTok fanatics) are unable to refute or argue against this fact and quickly downvote us because they have nothing to fight with. For example, one user [0] in the comments of this post went with a baseless claim that "TikTok ended censorship." and was quickly debunked [1] in the same conversation. If you believe them, you might as well also believe that Facebook and others 'respect your privacy'; whilst also using recommendation algorithms and graphs at the same time. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27550717 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27550717 [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27551195 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27551195
- justicezyx 5y agoYou know what? I think HN passes the threshold of being a community capable of self sustaining, and now is gradually moving into more like a reddit. In the sense, that HN now noticeably cannot accept non-conforming or non-positive statements. I am thinking about creating a HN copy that dont hide any comments at all. The only rule is that everyone has to share his real name and basic social identity (where you work, age etc.). I think people would be more mindful if they risk their actual reputation. Who knows, maybe I'll build it...
- bmarquez 5y ago
- Barrin92 5y agoit also has really out there content. I didn't expect much because I don't care much for pop culture but I found a crew of a ship who seemed to ferry stuff around the Caspian Sea and they pretty much documented most of their trip on tiktok. That was a surprise to me.
- radu_floricica 5y agoWomen? I haven't seen as many diggers and backhoes in the last 10 years as I've seen in the last 10 days. There's a guy doing lives from the cockpit of heavy forestry equipment. Give the algorythm a chance, it will find your niches.