5 ms·
The people arguing that Firefox has an edge because it maintains a separate browser engine (like the writer of this article) are going to have real difficulties
by roenxi 5y ago
The people arguing that Firefox has an edge because it maintains a separate browser engine (like the writer of this article) are going to have real difficulties making their argument. Ditto the attacks on Brave for not being private enough. The people who care about privacy should be more worried about getting caught in Google's web of properties than about privacy per-se - that company is bad news. And Firefox is more closely aligned with Google's interest than Brave is. Look at how much money Google has been funnelling to Firefox over the years.
Having a different engine is really more of an inconvenience than a strength - it means that sometimes pages will not work in Firefox. Having an independent engine was important when it was IE6 vs the open web. It doesn't matter much when the engines involved are BSD license vs GPL.
If Chrome was all proprietary licenses then having an independent engine would matter. But the internet likes to standardise on one, open, technology.
- bambax 5y agoYou may be right, and you may not be. It has to be good that there are more than exactly one engine, it means there is a discussion, some level of "forced openness". That wouldn't be possible if web developers could simply rely on undocumented quirks of a sole browser. It's possible that FF will die. But I think that would be extremely sad. For one, Manifest V3 would be forced upon the entire web => no more uOrigin.
- roenxi 5y ago> It has to be good that there are more than exactly one engine... Well, that is kinda the point. No, it doesn't. It might be worse than having one great de-facto standard engine. Having 2+ splits web developers in what they choose to support. In this instance, we literally have a young company (Brave Software, Inc) that chose to go head-to-head with Google. Their CEO is deeply entwined with the history of first Netscape then Mozilla/Firefox. They went with Chromium. That is a pretty searing indictment of the "an independent engine is important" argument. If Eich doesn't think Firefox is up for the challenge, what exactly is the gameplan here? Nobody is saying Mozilla has to die, whatever that means. But if there is an advantage to its existence that advantage is difficult to spot. Firefox doesn't even have the thriving extension ecosystem it could once boast about - they killed most of it off. There is nothing useful there except a different set of quirks.
- bambax 5y ago> Nobody is saying Mozilla has to die, whatever that means. To die means having so few users that development is abandoned and the teams disbanded. It could happen; I wish it doesn't; you seem to wish it does... because it would make the life of web developers a little simpler? But I don't think that's true; I think it's the opposite: web development would be a little more difficult if/when everything is controlled by just one company who decides unilaterally what can be done and what can't.
- roenxi 5y agoThere is no risk of everything being controlled by one company. That is why it is acceptable for there to only be one browser engine. Observe that Brave, inc is using the chromium engine in a way that opposes Google. Mozilla has developed a bunch of great features in the last few years. If they were developing on Chromium, most of the internet would have access to them. Instead, only a minor subset do. This is a bad strategy.
- roca 5y agoI don't think you understand how Chromium works. Google makes all the important decisions. People have advocated for independent governance (e.g. some kind of Chromium Foundation) but Google isn't interested. E.g. Brave opposes Google in some ways but they have no say in the development of Web standards implemented by Chromium.
- roenxi 5y agoIt is open source. If someone doesn't like a decision they can fork the codebase. Mozilla's Gecko has been beaten down to sub-double-digit market share, they're less relevant right now than when IE6 was >75% of the market. They have no power to influence the direction the web moves in. And yet life is going on better than ever. If you want a counterbalance to stop Google making the important decisions, Firefox has failed spectacularly. And yet Google doesn't have any power to move the web in a direction it doesn't want to go - because their engine is open source and that is what actually matters here.
- BrendanEich 5y agoNo, Manifest V2 support remains internally and for "Enterprise Chrome" customers. Therefore we at Brave have promised that we would support V2 on by default for extensions including uBO (not needed on Brave) and uMatrix. HTH
- gjsman-1000 5y agoFirefox has had a load of conflicts of interests that people don't want to mention. For example, >90% of their funding comes from Google for being the default search engine. That means Mozilla doesn't want to upset Google too much. As a result, what have we seen? Safari has added new privacy features, that should have been obvious, before Firefox. DuckDuckGo, which Mozilla staff generally recommend, isn't the default which is odd for how vocal Mozilla likes to be about how we're great for your privacy and an open web. The point is that by receiving >90% of their funding from Google, Mozilla can continue existing. And also be a hypocrite in their actions.
- dralley 5y ago>As a result, what have we seen? Safari has added new privacy features, that should have been obvious, before Firefox. Firefox has added plenty of "obvious" privacy features that no other browser has. Container tabs are amazing (and incredibly useful even apart from maintaining privacy). Where is uBlock Origin or uMatrix for Safari? They can't exist because Apple doesn't really care about the browser extension ecosystem and doesn't implement the APIs. Apple has very different priorities than Mozilla does, and that's not a dig at either of them. Given that, I'm not sure it's a great idea to assign ulterior motivations to the delay, especially since Firefox does eventually get those features. https://techcrunch.com/2021/02/24/mozilla-beefs-up-anti-cross-site-tracking-as-chrome-still-lags-on-privacy/ https://techcrunch.com/2021/02/24/mozilla-beefs-up-anti-cros...
- shadofx 5y ago>It doesn't matter much when the engines involved are BSD license vs GPL Without a competing engine, Google is free to cease development on Chromium and start a new private fork, and autoupdate all Chrome browsers to that new fork. Then they can add all sorts of web features that only they support. Every browser dependent on Chromium will fall behind in security updates and web features, and become more unusable than Firefox is today.
- roenxi 5y agoIf Google did that, we'd be better off with the Mozilla corporation taking over Chromium development than continuing to develop Gecko. The erosion of interest in Firefox over the years raises a pretty basic question: if Google followed through with that scenario, how effective would Firefox be? They're got steamrolled in the last decade with massive amounts of funding (from Google). Brave is literally showing that if someone wants to compete with Google, they're going to start with chromium as a base. Your argument is similar to "if someone wants to compete with Google, they need to be able to use Gecko/Webkit!". People with skin in the game are saying whatever the theoretical merits are to your argument, it is wrong. Gecko isn't part of the competitive equation any more.