3 ms·
> This sounds like pop science but might actually be real science- would like to know if there's any sort of listing out there determining how much dopamine is
by astrange 5y ago
> This sounds like pop science but might actually be real science- would like to know if there's any sort of listing out there determining how much dopamine is elevated by different activities.
Unfortunately that wouldn't prevent it from being pop science. What does it mean that "dopamine is elevated"? Elevated where, how was it measured, and what is the supposed effect of it being elevated?
It is true that amphetamines work by increasing dopamine in specific areas of the brain, but that doesn't mean the rest of this is valid. Also note that pretty much everything else people say about neurotransmitters is bunk, depression is not caused by lack of serotonin and more doesn't make you happier.
- javert 5y agoWhat is depression caused by, in your opinion? I have my own view, just want to see if yours is similar to mine or is interesting in some other way.
- astrange 5y agoNo idea. All we know is that antidepressants probably don’t work by increasing serotonin levels.
- milesvp 5y agoThere's actually research around this. I don't have references to any of the papers I read 10+ years ago, but the field is ripe with data since it's gotten easier to measure things. One of the surprising results in this area, is that contrary to what was believed 20 years ago, dopamine levels rise prior to an anticipated reward. That is to say, we learn that some thing that our body "really wants" is coming and the brain gets flooded with dopamine before the thing is introduced into our body, or the event actually happens. So, like with sugary food, dopamine will peak before we've ingested it, possibly before we even even put the food in our mouth. This was a very unexpected discovery based on how we thought dopamine worked. This is why ritual can be so important for a lot of behaviors, the repeated actions create an anticipatory effect in the brain that allows for sort of a bigger positive feedback loop. I wish I could find the paper it was a big enough deal, I thought it might be easy to google. Here's a paper from around the period I was thinking in any event if you are actually interested in how these things are measured. "Dopamine in motivational control: rewarding, aversive, and alerting" https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3032992/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3032992/ That will lead you to over 266 referenced papers, and I'm sure the ability to measure has only gotten better in the last 10 years. I will warn you though, this is a total rabbit hole. I used to casually study neurobiology, and it's an amazingly fascinating topic.